Germany: New liability for second medical use
Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX
Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Germany: New liability for second medical use

The most recent decision of the Düsseldorf Appeal Court of January 9 2019 (Case No. I-2 U 27/18) in the legal dispute concerning the active substance fulvestrant contributes to solidifying the new liability requirement of "sufficient scope of use". This was formulated by the court for the first time in the Östrogenblocker decision of May 5 2017 (Case No. I-2 W 6/17). Subject to the proceedings was European patent EP1272195B1, which protects the use of fulvestrant in the preparation of a medicament for the treatment of a patient with breast cancer who was previously treated with an aromatase inhibitor and tamoxifen and where such previous treatment failed.

The appeal court upheld the Regional Court's decision (Case No: 4c O 46/17) which was in effect that a sufficient scope of use could not be proven by the patentee. In this context, the court formulated a two-step programme: firstly, it is a matter for the court to decide that there has been patent-compliant use to a sufficient extent and, secondly, that the generic company could not have been completely unaware of this fact. The probability of such a judicial finding being made increases with the number of patent-compliant use cases that have demonstrably occurred.

Further, the court stated that there could be particular outstanding benefits of the patented use compared to other therapeutic purposes which invite use of the preparation in accordance with the patent. Despite this jurisprudence in Germany, which, in a patentee-friendly manner, has come to a wide interpretation of the scope of protection of second medical use patents, the Düsseldorf Appeal Court has shown that the requirements for demonstrating these liability criteria can be stringent. But at least it is clear that a skinny label is no longer sufficient to avoid liability.

However, patent owners have an even harder time before the English courts. In the Warner-Lambert case concerning the drug pregabalin, the UK Supreme Court made clear in its decision of November 14 2018 (Case No. [2018] UKSC 56) that there is no liability on the part of the manufacturer based on foreseeability of the patented use. Especially Lord Sumption and Lord Reed recommended a new test, termed "outward presentation". According to this test, the only decisive factor for liability is how the product is presented after its manufacture. This is comparable with the German requirement of "manifest arrangement" ("sinnfällige Herrichtung"). Even if the Supreme Court addressed the question of infringement only in the context of an obiter dictum, it is now obvious that the UK court does not intend to follow Germany's patentee-friendly jurisprudential line.

steif.jpg
zorr-ulrike.jpg

Marco Stief

Ulrike Zorr


Maiwald Patentanwalts- und Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH

Elisenhof, Elisenstr 3D-80335, Munich, GermanyTel: +49 89 74 72 660 Fax: +49 89 77 64 24info@maiwald.euwww.maiwald.eu

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Based on surveys covering more than 25,000 in-house lawyers, the series provides insights into what law firms must score highly on when pitching to in-house counsel
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
Tony Nguyen, who returned to Fish & Richardson this month after a year travelling overseas, tells Managing IP how and why he took the plunge
Tom Treutler, who previously managed the Vietnamese office of Tilleke & Gibbins, has joined East IP
Counsel discuss upcoming AI and data privacy legislation and what they’ve learned since Chile joined the Madrid Protocol
INTA has postponed its planned Annual Meeting in Dubai, but the organisation should think carefully about whether it wants to go there at all
The firm has named its new managing director after its former Asia head resigned earlier this year
As law firms explore how best to support clients at the UPC, members of the UPCLA network believe they have found the best of both worlds
The Industry Patent Quality Charter hosted a conference in which it discussed the importance of granting high-quality patents
Julia Holden explains why, if she weren’t in IP, she would be directing and producing live English-language theatre
Gift this article