Google prevails in Android attack

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Google prevails in Android attack

Case of the Year: Oracle v Google

java.jpg

The result

Google overcame Oracle’s patent claims but jury was hung on copyright infringement

The impact

Several lessons on APIs and copyright, and the Android system emerges stronger

In August 2010, Oracle filed suit against Google for patent and copyright infringement in the US District Court for the Northern District of California, in the first major attack against the Android operating system. The case was so complex it demanded a six-week jury trial with separate phases for the patent and copyright claims.

In the copyright leg of the suit, the jury found that Google infringed "the overall structure, sequence and organization" of 37 of Oracle's copyrighted Application Programming Interface (API) packages, which are used by software programs to communicate with each other. But the San Francisco jury could not decide whether Google's use of those works constituted fair use under US law. It also found that Google's use of the documentation for those 37 packages did not infringe.

Other uses were found to infringe, but the jury also said that Oracle engaged in conduct that could have led Google to believe it did not need a licence to use the structure, sequence and organisation of the 37 APIs. Still, the jurors said that Google had failed to prove it relied on that conduct in deciding to use the APIs, so the verdict had criticisms for both sides.

In a separate verdict on the patent claims, another jury found Oracle had failed to prove whether Google infringed patents RE38,104 and 6,061,520 by a preponderance of the evidence, and whether Google willfully infringed the patents by clear and convincing evidence.

Both aspects of the case are now on appeal to the Federal Circuit, but there were some clear lessons to be drawn from Judge William Alsup's opinion on the copyrightability of the Java APIs.

First, Alsup deemed the code for the Java API packages functional because Oracle requires identical method specifications to carry out the same function. "When there is only one way to write something, the merger doctrine bars anyone from claiming exclusive copyright ownership of that expression," wrote the judge. To get around this, Michael Lasky of Burr & Forman told Managing IP that Oracle (then Sun Microsystems) could have made it possible to provide other ways to link APIs with each other. "The lesson is: don't take it all. Leave some on the table," he said.

Secondly, Lasky said that registering entire works under one registration often leaves them open to so-called de minimis arguments, meaning the infringed part is so small as to be insignificant. Of the 37 API packages Oracle asserted, the jury found nine lines (or 3%) of code infringed. Oracle could have registered its most critical lines of code separately early in product development.

Lastly, while Alsup did not dispute that Oracle's methods were creative, he made a distinction between patents and copyrights. "Such inventions – the concept and functionality level – are protectable only under the Patent Act," he said. Oracle might have done better if it had filed more patent applications instead of relying largely on copyright.

Case details

Oracle v Google

Copyrights: 37 packages in the Java API

Patents: Seven Java-related patents

Offices: USPTO; US Copyright Office

Patent numbers: 6,125,447; 6,192,476; 5,966,702; 7,426,720; RE38,104; 6,910,205; and 6,061,520

Patent/copyright holder: Oracle

Other party: Google

Court: US District Court for the Northern District of California (on appeal to Federal Circuit)

Case number: 3:10-CV-03561

For Oracle: Boies Schiller & Flexner, Morrison & Foerster

For Google: King & Spalding, Keker & Van Nest, Greenberg Traurig


This case was selected as one of Managing IP’s Cases of the Year for 2012.

To see the rest, click on one of the cases below.

The 10 cases of the year

A fillip for the EU pharmaceutical sector

Relief for trade mark owners in red sole saga

Australian TV streaming service held to be illegal

Smartphone war hits front page in the US

Liberalising the EU’s software market

India allows parallel imports

Victory for fair dealing in Canada

Lacoste loses its trade mark in China

Google prevails in Android attack

EU test case clarifies class headings

Ten you might have missed

Canada: Ambiguous claims can invalidate patents

Russia: Certainty on parallel imports

Italy: TV formats win copyright for the first time

First FRAND cases litigated worldwide

Monsanto loses in Brazil

Data exclusivity backed by Mexican courts

China: A shift over OEM manufacturing

Authors in the US able to reclaim joint copyrights

Germany: Knitted trainers a sign of the future

India: Financial Times loses trade mark

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

The IP services provider is targeting further expansion as cost and efficiency pressures push law firms and in-house teams to rethink how they manage global portfolios
Two experienced UPC practitioners join the UK IP boutique’s growing German operation, with further recruitment planned as the firm expands in Europe
The Australian IP firm is taking on bigger rivals in Southeast Asia, betting that agility and transparent pricing can help it stand out
The firm has brought in former Weil IP leaders Doug Lumish and Jeff Homrig as it looks to deepen its patent, trade secrets and ITC bench
Bird & Bird helps GSK score a major injunction as the battle to become the UPC’s busiest division tightens, and overall filings reach a new monthly high
CEO Annette Bach explains how the Danish IP consultancy plans to build on its 65% profit growth while keeping external investment off the table for now
Belgian attorneys have revived fax systems to protect clients’ filing rights, while uncertainty over exposed patent data has left firms struggling to answer questions about the breach
In his first interview since leaving Weil Gotshal & Manges, Chris Henry explains why he returned to Latham and how he plans to bolster its tech disputes offering
As GTA VI underlines the extraordinary value of gaming franchises, lawyers at Clifford Chance say investors need to know the IP behind their next deal can deliver the growth they are paying for
As ‘big law’ invests in IP litigation, trial firms are emerging as a valuable source of seasoned courtroom talent
Gift this article