Managing IP is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2023

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Commercial suicide or good business sense?

Judges, IP offices, parties and even some lawyers are in favour of mediation in IP cases. So why is it not more common?

arnold-richard-200.jpg

I was at a seminar on mediation organised by the UK IPO and hosted by Wiggin in London last night for companies and trade associations in the creative industries

The Institute of Trade Mark Attorneys is holding another event on Tuesday, which suggests that the topic is on something of a roll at the moment (it’s also the subject of Managing IP’s next cover story). So what’s going on?

The new push to sell the benefits of mediation has trickled down from the 2009 Jackson report into ways to rein in costs in civil litigation in the UK. In it, Lord Justice Jackson recommended there be a “serious campaign” to ensure judges, lawyers and businesses know about the benefits of ADR.

Mr Justice Arnold (right) spoke last night, and it was clear that he is already an enthusiast (“It works so go and do it” were his closing words).

The speakers also made clear that there was plenty in it for businesses, particularly for those who want to maintain a working relationship with the parties with whom they are in dispute. As mediator Andrew Hildebrand said: “It can be hard to reassure the other side that you want to do business after litigation. It certainly isn’t helped by the words ‘we have been instructed by’.”

But what’s in it for law firms? After all, there must be pressure in the partners’ dining room on litigation lawyers to bring in the cash, and the biggest cheques invariably follow trips to the High Court (and beyond).

Wiggin lawyer Simon Baggs referred to that in his presentation, saying that barristers and solicitors had been asking him whether a talk advocating mediation didn’t amount to commercial suicide.

But when one audience member asked why private practice lawyers would encourage clients to settle through mediation, Baggs said that it was a matter of economics: it was in his interest to keep his clients satisfied, he said. “There’s lots to be said for clients leaving mediation happy. They tell people and that means we get more buyers of legal services. Any referral is good.”

Although there’s an element of “well he would say that, wouldn’t he?” in his comments, one of Baggs’s clients later told me that he was right: good law firms focus on keeping existing clients happy – and returning – rather than burning them with one piece of expensive, but traumatising, litigation, especially when legal budgets are under pressure.

“We talk,” she said. “The word soon gets around.”

If you have experience of mediation (good or bad) and want to share those with us for our forthcoming article, do let us know.

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas has hired former Anand & Anand partner Swati Sharma and hopes to compete with specialist IP firms
Rapporteur-Judge András Kupecz ruled that education and training weren’t legitimate reasons for a member of the public to access documents
Searches for comparison prior art will be a little easier, but practitioners will have to put more thought into claim construction and design patent titles
The Helsinki local division rejected AIM Sport’s request for a preliminary injunction in a dispute with rival Supponor
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis coverage from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
The FTC’s plans to scrutinise improperly listed Orange Book patents could make these listings more important in litigation, but firms should be looking at this anyway
Counsel at Debevoise & Plimpton explain how they helped food delivery business Grubhub avoid a preliminary injunction at the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
European lawyers tell Managing IP how the legal market is reacting to the first few months of the UPC and why cases are set to take off
The ban could be extended or cancelled, depending on whether Judge Pauline Newman cooperates with an investigation, the Judicial Council of the Federal Circuit stated
Sources say some China-based lawyers are prepared to take large pay cuts to join stable practices, but most firms are sceptical about new hires