Defining "the public" in copyright disputes

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Defining "the public" in copyright disputes

A panellist called for clarification about what defines “the public” in copyright disputes in Asia in yesterday’s “Copyright aspects of embedding, framing and hyperlinking” workshop at the AIPPI Congress

Tony Yeo, director at Drew & Napier, said Singapore has no definition of “the public” when the issue of making something “freely available to the public” is being discussed, adding that this contrasts with the position in Japan.

He pointed to the case in Singapore of RecordTV v MediaCorp TV, in which RecordTV used an internet-based digital video recorder to make MediaCorp programs available online. The court of appeals found that the registered users did not constitute “the public” because the communications were made “privately and individually”.

“This is an issue touched on by the Aereo case, and that went the other way,” said Yeo. Perhaps if Aereo had come out earlier, the Singapore decision might have gone the other way.”

Fellow panellist Dale Nelson of Warner Brothers noted the language of the Aereo decision talking about performance being activated at a “’turn of the knob’—a click on a website”. “The Aereo decision found direct liability for public performance so I think it provides an opportunity to rethink some of the decisions that have been made about direct infringement,” Nelson said.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Sources explain why return-to-office mandates could hamper efficiency at the USPTO
The Unified Patent Court surpassing 700 cases and a row between Apple and PanOptis were among the top talking points this week
Partners at four firms explain how they help clients join in the hype around the big game without attracting the NFL’s wrath
We discuss how law firms are using AI, whether remote working has resulted in cost-savings, and what corporate counsel want from their advisers when it comes to DEI
Matthew Yeates, managing director at Integrated IP, discusses its acquisition of Clark IP and reveals further expansion plans
Paul Lee discusses moving from venture capital to IP, why lawyers are becoming more receptive to tech, and why he starts his day with a cold plunge
Barbara Lawton, a counsellor and mental health trainer at wellbeing charity Jonathan’s Voice, outlines tips for engaging with vulnerable people
New partner Amir Ghavi, who will help launch the group, says he expects more lateral hires in the coming weeks
Counsel at three firms reveal the tools they’re using to generate patent invalidity claim charts and why they’re making investments in the technology
Eric Lee says the firm’s thought leadership on artificial intelligence convinced him to move
Gift this article