Beastie Boys’ copyright win, Hatch calls for USPTO director, Hershey’s sues pot co-op, dispute over “Mormon”, Harper Lee kills lawsuit – the week in IP
Managing IP is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Beastie Boys’ copyright win, Hatch calls for USPTO director, Hershey’s sues pot co-op, dispute over “Mormon”, Harper Lee kills lawsuit – the week in IP

Monster Beverage being ordered to pay the Beastie Boys $1.7 million, Orrin Hatch slamming the Obama administration for not appointing a USPTO director, Hershey’s suing a marijuana cooperative, .xyz becoming the number one gTLD, and Harper Lee ending a copyright lawsuit against a museum were among the intellectual property stories hitting the headlines this week

Below is a selection of intellectual property stories attracting attention on the internet in the past week that were not covered on (see the bottom of this blog post for the top stories published by Managing IP this week).

beastie20boys.jpg Beasties win fight for their copyright

The Beastie Boys this week won a lawsuit against Monster Beverage and were awarded $1.7 million. A federal jury in Manhattan ruled in favour of the hip hop group two years after the lawsuit was filed over the use of their songs in a promotional video.

Monster included parts of Beastie Boys songs “Sabotage”, “So What’cha Want”, “Make Some Noise” and “Looking Down the Barrel of a Gun” in a video promoting a snowboarding competition sponsored by Monster.

The trial lasted eight days and included testimony by band members Ad-Rock and Mike D. Beastie Boy co-founder Adam “MCA” Yauch died in 2012 shortly before the video was put online. Yauch included in his will his wish that his music not be used for commercial purposes, a stand the Beastie Boys had held throughout their career.

The latest case follows the band in March settling with toymaker GoldieBlox for the use of song “Girls” in an online video.

orrin20hatch.jpg “Inexcusable” absence of USPTO director

Senator Orrin Hatch, a Republican from Utah, this week slammed the Obama administration for not appointing a director of the USPTO for the past 16 months.

“Leaving the agency without a permanent director for nearly a year and a half without so much as a public explanation is inexcusable,” Hatch wrote in a letter to Obama on Monday.

David Kappos left the post in January last year. Michelle Lee was named deputy director last December but the director spot remains unfilled.

“By all accounts Deputy Director Michelle Lee has done an admirable job juggling the functions and duties of both director and deputy director. But this arrangement simply cannot continue,” said Hatch. “Without a director backed by presidential nomination and Senate confirmation, the USPTO does not have a leader who can engage in the type of strategic and long-term planning that is crucial for ensuring the USPTO’s continued effectiveness.”

Hatch said Lee is constrained by legitimate questions about whether her appointment was consistent with statutory requirements. “I hope you did not casually disregard the clear statutory requirement that the deputy director be nominated by the director,” said Hatch. “In any case, the question underscores Ms Lee does not possess the same clear mandate as would a presidentially-nominated and Senate-confirmed director. Leaving Ms Lee to shoulder the burden of USPTO leadership alone is unfair, untenable, and unacceptable for our country’s intellectual property agency.”

Hatch said the USPTO is embarking on initiatives such as opening satellite offices and implementing post-grant review programmes, and the absence of director makes these “needlessly complicated”.

Hershey’s sues marijuana co-op

US candy manufacturer The Hershey Company is suing a Seattle marijuana cooperative for infringing its trade marks to sell cannabis products. The complaint was filed in a district court on Tuesday against Conscious Care Cooperative and says the cooperative’s actions have “tarnished” Hershey’s.


The cooperative was selling products such as “Reefer’s Peanut Butter Cups”, “Kush Peanut Butter Cups” and “Mr Dankbar” that closely resemble The Hershey Company’s Reese’s and Mr Goodbar products in name and design.

The cooperative sold its products out of two shops in North Seattle and Greenwood and online.

The Hershey Company also filed a similar lawsuit in Colorado on Tuesday against another company.

to20kill20a20mockingbird150.jpg Harper Lee to kill “Mockingbird” lawsuit

A judge in a federal court has dismissed a lawsuit filed by author Harper Lee against a museum in her South Alabama hometown of Monroeville. The “To Kill a Mockingbird” author and lawyers for the Monroe County Heritage Museum filed a joint motion to end the suit.

The judge had reinstated the case two weeks ago at the request of Lee. She and the museum had settled the case in February but the agreement was not signed.

The lawsuit was filed last year after the museum used her name and that of “To Kill a Mockingbird”. Lee claimed the museum was taking advantage of her trade marks to sell souvenirs.

mormon20match20screen20grab.jpg The casebook of Mormon

A dispute has broken out over the use of the term “Mormon” on a dating site. Intellectual Reserve, which manages the intellectual property rights of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, has sued the website “Mormon Match” for trade mark infringement. The website offers dating services for members of the church.

Intellectual Reserve concedes that the term “Mormon” can be used to describe church members generally but says that its family of trade marks using the term – such as “Mormon Tabernacle Choir” – could lead to confusion. The Electronic Frontier Foundation has filed an amicus brief arguing that ‘Mormon” is an indisputably descriptive term so its use in the name of the website is fair and legal.

"The name of this service simply describes what it's doing – matching up Mormons," said EFF intellectual property director Corynne McSherry. "Trade marks are supposed to be used to protect from unfair competition, not to stifle a small business or to control language."

.xyz debuts at number one

The .xyz domain name made its debut as the number one generic top-level domain (gTLD) this week. As of Friday June 6, the gTLD had 69,156 registrations, giving it a 7.01% share. This pushed it ahead of .club, which took the number one spot in May, which had 65,967 registrations as of Friday.

The .xyz domain name has caused controversy, with some saying its initial registration figures were questionable. Network Solutions has been accused of inflating .xyz’s numbers by registering names matching existing .com names.

Donuts Inc., the world's largest registry for new gTLDs, this month is making 16 new gTLDs available to the general public. In addition to the 16 gTLDs slated for general availability, Donuts will open another 16 gTLDs for "Sunrise" availability to trade mark holders.

Donuts, now eclipsing the six-month mark of its new gTLD general availability schedule, will continue rolling out new gTLDs on a weekly basis throughout the second half of 2014. By the end of this month, Donuts will have launched a total of 127 new gTLDs, and anticipates launching approximately 200 in total by the end of the programme.

"Demand for new gTLDs in the first five months of 2014 has outstripped our most aggressive benchmarks," Donuts co-founder and CEO Paul Stahura said.

Managing IP published the following stories this week, available to subscribers and trialists:

Eversheds hires South African IP team

Fees shifted in three cases following SCOTUS Octane decision

Delhi High Court affirms that tag lines and slogans are protectable as trade marks

Americas Women in Business Law Awards: 2014 winners

India’s patent owners get a reprieve from multiple validity challenges

WilmerHale adds partner in Palo Alto

Advocate General backs libraries’ right to digitise

On- screen and cache copies do not infringe, says CJEU

Trade mark renewals in Gambia: re-classification

Impact of SCOTUS 2014 patent verdicts already being felt

O’Melveny hires IP transactions partner Heather Meeker

Latham & Watkins adds IP litigator in Chicago

Former ITC unfair import investigations director joins MoFo

InterDigital and Samsung announce patent licence deal

SCOTUS rejects CAFC’s insolubly ambiguous test and expansion of inducement doctrine

Democratic Republic of Sào Tomé and Príncipe joins ARIPO

Interview: The life and times of a GSK patent

From the blog:

Things are not as bad as they seem at the Federal Circuit

Are TPP supporters talking to themselves?

Mediation – the question no one dares to ask


more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

The firm was among multiple winners at a record-breaking 2024 ceremony held in London on April 11
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
The Americas research cycle has commenced. Do not miss this opportunity to nominate your work!
Increased and new patent fees could affect prosecution strategies for law firms and companies, according to sources
Five former Oblon lawyers felt that joining Merchant & Gould would help them offer the right prices to entice clients
The UK may not be a UPC member but its firms are still acting in proceedings, with Carpmaels among the most prominent
Naomi Pearce of Pearce IP shares how she is helping her firm become a life sciences leader and how generous policies have helped attract top talent
The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal filed by Ocado, in what was a key test for transparency at the new court
Each week Managing IP speaks to a different IP lawyer or professional about their life and career
INTA is calling out ‘immoral’ unregistered attendees at the association’s annual meeting, but the debate is more nuanced
Gift this article