Are TPP supporters talking to themselves?

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Are TPP supporters talking to themselves?

Opponents of the Transpacific Partnership are increasingly vocal and making their concerns heard. But are supporters of the trade treaty missing the point?

Earlier this week, an online petition protesting against the Transpacific Partnership (TPP) was delivered to the Australian Parliament. Signed by 1.8 million internet users worldwide, the petition demanded that the details of the negotiations be made public (Like several other plurilateral treaties before it, a major criticism of the TPP concerns the secretive nature of the negotiations).

Despite the fact that governments increasingly laud the importance of intellectual property and innovation as drivers of the modern economy, there is also what many see as a countervailing anti-IP sentiment. INTA president Mei-Lan Stark alluded to this in an interview last month, and she cited it as one of the biggest challenges for those who work to increase IP protection. Stark notes that this sentiment, and the protests against the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement, seem to have taken IP owners by surprise. As she explained, “[ACTA was legislation] that had everybody's support but then suddenly was just unpalatable."

Not really unexpected

If rights holders were truly caught off guard by the anti-ACTA backlash, they have no excuse this time. A petition of 1.8 million internet users demanding a more transparent negotiation process, even taking into account the inflationary nature of internet petitions, shows that there is serious concern about the deal. A simple search for “TPP” on Google or the #TPP hashtag on Twitter also returns considerably more negative results than positive ones.

Furthermore, despite some attempts to make the TPP negotiation process more transparent, what has been done has fallen far short. TPP opponents, despite whatever faults one may find with their claims, often make arguments with direct reference to specific sections of the TPP. Many critics, like James Love of Public Knowledge International, have similarly provided detailed analysis of the draft versions coming from WikiLeaks.

Meanwhile, the US Trade Representative, despite having a webpage dedicated to the TPP, merely provides outlines broadly describing its positions while talking about the importance of IP protection. Similarly, supporters of the treaty, like the Global IP Center, attempt to debunk myths about the TPP by pointing to provisions from the US-Korea Trade Agreement as stand-ins for possible text in the TPP, rather than referencing the treaty itself.

Yelling past each other

The dialogue over the merits of the TPP at this point sounds more like an argument rather than a discussion. A good bit of the blame can be placed on supporters of the treaty, who seem content to talk past the detractors and ignore the details of their arguments. Many of those opposed to the TPP are likely not against IP protection on principle, but while they raise specific critiques and parse the language of leaked drafts, the treaty’s supporters provide what often sound like dismissive platitudes combined with a “seriously, just trust us” attitude.

Such a response does not help generate support for the TPP, and only further stokes anti-IP sentiment.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

A new foundation in Chile is giving women in the IP community the mentorship, and visibility they’ve long lacked
The EUIPO is keen to stress the benefits of mediation as a means of resolving IP disputes, but do roadblocks remain?
Åsa Gustafson, global patent paralegal manager at Zacco, provides insight into the world of a paralegal, explains how she keeps abreast of legal developments, and reveals a passion for weaving
Alif Gultom and Andrew Diamond of Januar Jahja and Partners explain why Indonesia must adopt reforms against bad-faith filings and safeguard its trademark system for the future
In the third episode of a podcast series celebrating the tenth anniversary of IP Inclusive, we discuss the ‘Women in IP’ network and the current state of diversity within the profession
Practitioners, including two ex USPTO directors, say the Patent Eligibility Restoration Act could restore clarity and predictability to US patent law, though concerns remain
News of an alliance between two Malaysian law firms and the launch of a self-help video aimed at supporting IP professionals through menopause were also among the top talking points
Speakers at the EUIPO’s IP Mediation Conference discussed how lawyers can act in tandem with clients during mediation, and the importance of showing a united front
A report that revealed top legal LinkedIn influencers are generating hundreds of thousands in advertising value is the push lawyers need to up their social media presence
Speakers at the EUIPO’s Mediation Conference say mediation can offer a ‘cathartic’ and effective alternative to litigation that IP owners should consider
Gift this article