Judges reveal FRAND thinking

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Judges reveal FRAND thinking

How would courts in Germany, South Korea, China, Japan and the US rule in FRAND cases? Leading judges from each jurisdiction explained what they would do in a mock trial at the AIPPI Congress

Presided over by an international panel of judges, the case involved a dispute between Angel, a non-practising entity holding a standards-essential patent, and Beast, a manufacturer of motor oil barrels that use the standard technology.

Patent ‘545 covers a barrel design that allows the contents to be poured out without leaving any residue through use of a sloping surface near the opening and using a screw cap. Beast’s product has a sloping surface but uses a breakable seal. The patent was granted to an inventor called Lou Zephyr, who submitted the design to the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) straight after filing for the patent, though did not disclose the filing until after its design was picked. Zephyr signed a declaration agreeing to license the patent under FRAND terms. Soon after, Angel bought the patent from Zephyr.

Angel brought the case before the AIPPI court, seeking monetary damages and injunctive relief.

National differences

The case highlighted a number of differences between jurisdictions. Chief judge Ki Young Kim quickly established that there was no literal infringement, but oral arguments concerned whether the doctrine of equivalence applied. Angel argued that though Beast’s product did not use a screw cap, the essential elements were the same and therefore infringing under the doctrine. Beast, on the other hand, asserted that the breakaway seal changes the essential function so there was no equivalence.

Another major issue concerned whether Angel violated its fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory obligations under the ISO and whether it acted in bad faith by not disclosing its patent filing until after the ISO adopted its standard. The court also wrestled with the question whether Zephyr’s declaration agreeing to grant licences on FRAND terms constituted an offer to enter into a contract for Beast to accept.

After nearly two hours of spirited questioning and bantering from the panel, as well as an impromptu happy birthday cheer for expert witness Hwang Lee, the court rendered its decision: Beast infringed Angel’s patent. It also found that while Angel had agreed to license the patent under FRAND terms, no agreement existed between the parties. The court granted Angel’s request for monetary damages and injunctive relief.

After the court handed down the decision, the judges revealed their individual thoughts on the case and highlighted differences in their own jurisdiction’s laws. Chief Judge Randall Rader of the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit pointed out that the doctrine of equivalence is much more limited under US law, and the issue of infringement would probably have been decided differently. Judge Xia Luo of the the People’s Supreme Court of China noted that while she agreed on the infringement finding, she differed on the issue of granting an injunction, given the social cost in preventing goods from entering the market.

The panel consisted of judges Ki Young Kim (Seoul District Court), Peter Meier-Beck (German Federal Court), Makiko Takabe (IP High Court of Japan), Xia Luo (Supreme People’s Court of China), and Randall Rader (Federal Circuit Court of the United States).

Min Ho Lee of Lee & Ko and Seong Tahk Ahn of Central International Law Firm acted as counsel for the plaintiff, while Jehyun Kim of Y P Lee, Mock & Partners and David Chun of Ropes & Gray represented the defendant. Hwang Lee of Korean University Law School was the expert witness, and Ralph Nack of Noerr LLP moderated the session.


Download the AIPPI Congress News, published by Managing IP from Seoul, Korea, from our conference newspapers page.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

The firm has taken the bold step of ditching the billable hour as its default pricing mechanism – watch now as rivals follow suit
The IP services provider is targeting further expansion as cost and efficiency pressures push law firms and in-house teams to rethink how they manage global portfolios
Two experienced UPC practitioners join the UK IP boutique’s growing German operation, with further recruitment planned as the firm expands in Europe
The Australian IP firm is taking on bigger rivals in Southeast Asia, betting that agility and transparent pricing can help it stand out
The firm has brought in former Weil IP leaders Doug Lumish and Jeff Homrig as it looks to deepen its patent, trade secrets and ITC bench
Bird & Bird helps GSK score a major injunction as the battle to become the UPC’s busiest division tightens, and overall filings reach a new monthly high
CEO Annette Bach explains how the Danish IP consultancy plans to build on its 65% profit growth while keeping external investment off the table for now
Belgian attorneys have revived fax systems to protect clients’ filing rights, while uncertainty over exposed patent data has left firms struggling to answer questions about the breach
In his first interview since leaving Weil Gotshal & Manges, Chris Henry explains why he returned to Latham and how he plans to bolster its tech disputes offering
As GTA VI underlines the extraordinary value of gaming franchises, lawyers at Clifford Chance say investors need to know the IP behind their next deal can deliver the growth they are paying for
Gift this article