Why Samsung's design infringement defence will fail: The takeaway
Managing IP is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Why Samsung's design infringement defence will fail: The takeaway

In view of all the odds stacked against it, there can be little question that Samsung has an uphill battle with respect to its non-infringement case on its tablets, largely due to some crucial pre-trial rulings

Return to previous page

Christopher Carani, McAndrews Held & Malloy

Whether dealing with utility patents or design patents, this case serves as a reminder that pre-trial rulings can often be case determinative, or at least shine some light on where the case is headed. In design patent cases, because the ultimate question boils down to the degree of similarity between the patented design and the accused design, two pieces of information that remain the same whether at the beginning or end of a case, a court’s infringement finding on motions for preliminary injunction (albeit preliminary) can have a lasting effect – even potentially providing the foundation for a directed verdict. Here, Koh has made strong pronouncements regarding Samsung’s tablet infringement; it is hard to see how she can back away from those conclusions.

Samsung’s main lifeline would be to unearth and introduce close prior art designs. But here, due to an apparent failure to abide by discovery deadlines, the court is preventing Samsung from relying upon many of its best prior art references at the trial. Thus, this case also serves as a stark reminder of the drastic consequences that can arise when a party fails to meet discovery deadlines.


Christopher Carani is a shareholder at McAndrews Held & Malloy in Chicago.

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
Law firms that pay close attention to their client relationships are more likely to win repeat work, according to a survey of nearly 29,000 in-house counsel
The EMEA research period is open until May 31
Practitioners analyse a survey on how law firms prove value to their clients and reflect on why the concept can be hard to pin down
The winner of Managing IP’s Life Achievement Award discusses 50 years in IP law and how even he can’t avoid imposter syndrome
Saya Choudhary of Singh & Singh explains how her team navigated nine years of litigation to secure record damages of $29 million and the lessons learned along the way
The full list of finalists has been revealed and the winners will be presented on June 20 at the Metropolitan Club in New York
A team of IP and media law specialists has joined from SKW Schwarz alongside a former counsel at Sky
The Irish government has delayed a planned referendum on whether Ireland should join the Unified Patent Court, prompting concern about when a vote may take place
With more than 250 winners recognised during the ceremony, there are many reasons to be positive about the health of the IP industry in EMEA
Gift this article