Analysis: why the Supreme Court overturned two patent specialists

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Analysis: why the Supreme Court overturned two patent specialists

November 02 2011
middcrownct01-0-69.jpg

Mr Justice Kitchin and Lord Justice Jacob were clear that HGS’s patent for the Neutrokine-a protein was invalid for lacking industrial application. But five Supreme Court judges today disagreed. Why?

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

United KingdomNewsPatentsEurope
more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Patents
Ahmed_Natasha.jpg
New Akin hire excited to build tech transactions group
Natasha Ahmed said she was drawn to the firm’s commitment to artificial intelligence and tech transactions
Rani Mehta, May 13 2025
Patents
50th anniversary champagne bottle balloon pop
50 not out: Murgitroyd reflects on IP ‘pioneer’ role
As it celebrates its 50th anniversary this year, the firm discusses private equity interest in IP, why the UPC is a key priority, and being a ‘strategic adviser’ to clients
Max Walters, May 13 2025
Patents
Rukin_Thomas_Oslo.jpg
Five minutes with…Thomas Rukin, Zacco
Thomas Rukin discusses IP due diligence, his joy at seeing colleagues succeed, and taking inspiration from Marcus Aurelius
May 13 2025
Patents
AdobeStock_171685519.jpg
Weekly take: Why India may regret missing open legal market boat
The UK-India trade deal doesn’t mention legal services, showing India has again failed to agree on a move that could help foreign firms and local practitioners
Sukanya Sarkar, May 09 2025
Managing IP Awards
MIP EMEABaker.jpg
Meet the Managing IP award winners: Baker McKenzie talks ‘growth mode’
Eva-Maria Strobel reveals some of the firm’s IP achievements and its approach to client relationships
Rani Mehta, May 09 2025
Trademarks
Magnet attracting people. Digital social marketing, Customer att
Talent Tracker update: innovation desires drive US partner moves
Lateral hires at Thompson Hine and Pierson Ferdinand said they were inspired by fresh business opportunities and innovative strategies at their new firms
Rani Mehta, May 09 2025
Patents
Nokia-comp.jpg
This week on MIP: Nokia loses licensing expert | Tesla TMs face hurdles
The launch of a new IP insurance product and INTA hiring a former USPTO commissioner were also among the top talking points this week
Sukanya Sarkar, May 09 2025
Patents
BradGraveline2.png
How Sheppard Mullin beat US government in $170m airport case
The firm explains how it secured a $170.6 million verdict against the government in a patent dispute surrounding airport technology, and why the case led to interest from other inventors
Rani Mehta, May 08 2025
Patents
technology var decision no goal.The video assistant referee scene a match official in football stadium.
UPC update: VAR patent decision | Confidentiality club rejig
Developments of note included the court partially allowing a claim concerning confidentiality clubs and a decision involving technology used in football matches
Max Walters, May 08 2025
Patents
TWF Patent team.jpg
Taylor Wessing poaches Pinsent Masons IP partner for Paris launch
The firm said adding capability in the French capital completes its coverage of all major patent litigation jurisdictions as it strives for UPC excellence
Max Walters, May 07 2025
Gift this article