Pharma IP Summit: Timing of the essence when filing patents
Managing IP is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Pharma IP Summit: Timing of the essence when filing patents

Industry experts discuss patent filing strategies for companies based in the US, China and beyond



Knowing when to file patents and devising a corresponding strategy are essential when entering the US market, according to speakers at the 4th China Pharma IP Summit in Shanghai.


“The advantage with delaying filing until a drug is close to the investigational new drug stage is that you can get rid of any freedom-to-operate (FTO) issues,” said Andy Zhang, senior corporate counsel at Sunovion Pharmaceutical. By this stage, it’s possible to draft claims with strong validity, he said. Additionally, the project team can generate data to support the invention and there is a more effective patent term for the drug, Zhang added, but he pointed out that the drug may miss out on patent term extension.

On the other hand, it might be advantageous to build in a developed drug candidate and file early to avoid being stopped by any competitors, Zhang said. For secondary filings, he added, it is still best to file earlier because generics will be watching the pipeline more closely and there might be FTO issues.

Focusing on startups, Teresa Lavoie, principal at Fish & Richardson, said that it is best to delay filing as much as possible. “Startups want to have a longer term because they need to have a portfolio to build interest with key opinion leaders and investors. It’s important to establish yourself in the target space to attract big pharma.”

Caihui Li, senior IP director at 3SBio Group, shared from her experience that it is best to file as soon as possible, both in China and the US, on the premise that the drug data is sufficient.

An important point to remember for generics going into the US is the on-sale bar provision, which specifies that a drug can’t be patented if it has been on sale for over a year before the filing. “This is something to keep in mind for companies that are outsourcing production or have contract manufacturing because it could affect patentability,” said Lavoie.

One question to ask is where to file when there are multiple inventors, for instance if a drug was developed by both Chinese and US inventors. Lavoie suggested that in this situation, it would be best to do a PCT filing in China as such filings are in English, meaning there is no burden of translation, and then ask for an expedited review in the US. Zhang added that sometimes senior executives may be nominated as inventors, which could make a patent unenforceable, so having accuracy on who the inventor is key.

Having a good analysis of a country’s industry landscape is key. “It’s important to have a deep understanding of where the product will be made and sold, prospective partners, and how easy it is to get protection in the country,” said Zhang. Other issues to keep in mind are the patentability of the drug in the country, the difficulty of prosecution and whether enforcement is a problem. It’s about balancing and adjusting based on the business’s interests, he said.

“Each company should have a filing list and adjust according to the geographical area,” said Zhang. “For instance, for some drugs targeting infectious disease, it might be better to file in Southeast Asian and African countries because of the commercial opportunities.”

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

The firm was among multiple winners at a record-breaking 2024 ceremony held in London on April 11
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
The Americas research cycle has commenced. Do not miss this opportunity to nominate your work!
Increased and new patent fees could affect prosecution strategies for law firms and companies, according to sources
Five former Oblon lawyers felt that joining Merchant & Gould would help them offer the right prices to entice clients
The UK may not be a UPC member but its firms are still acting in proceedings, with Carpmaels among the most prominent
Naomi Pearce of Pearce IP shares how she is helping her firm become a life sciences leader and how generous policies have helped attract top talent
The Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal filed by Ocado, in what was a key test for transparency at the new court
Each week Managing IP speaks to a different IP lawyer or professional about their life and career
INTA is calling out ‘immoral’ unregistered attendees at the association’s annual meeting, but the debate is more nuanced
Gift this article