Editorial: The practitioners of ‘black arts’ need to watch their reputation

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Editorial: The practitioners of ‘black arts’ need to watch their reputation

The "red-headed step-daughter of IP" is finally getting some attention

This, I was told by a US design patents lawyer, is one derogatory term for his area of practice in the United States. I hadn't heard it before, but these jibes clearly stick. "When you told people what area of law you worked in, they used to put on a pitying face. It was like saying you were a chiropractor, rather than a doctor," he says. "I was once described in a news piece as practising the 'dark arts' of design patents."

Some of that reputation comes from "a few shysters" who used to advertise guaranteed patents for inventors. Of course, they would just get the applicant a design patent and usually he didn't know the difference. In the US and elsewhere, they were also seen as the poor relation in IP because of their relative ineffectiveness.

Copenhagen INTA design

Apple v Samsung changed all that. In Europe, the case suddenly focused attention on the hundreds of Community designs Apple had been registering for years. In the US, Apple's damages award last month led to predictions that everyone would begin prioritising designs, both in product development and IP strategy. INTA's first conference dedicated to designs (#INTADK), held in Copenhagen last month, was therefore well timed. "It's great to have everyone here," commented one lawyer. "We spent all this time in the shadows, and now we are out in the media spotlight."

All lawyers reported an increase in enquiries about design rights, both from existing and potential clients. But some were also cautious about a potential backlash. "I wouldn't be surprised if some US congressman who wants to make a name for himself starts saying that design patents need to be reined in," said one lawyer – even though Apple's victory could easily be seen as an American innovator being protected from a foreign imitator.

Certainly, the damages awarded for design infringement in the US can seem disproportionate. Unlike patent infringement, the damages the California jury had to decide on were for all lost profits – rather than just those lost because of the particular, infringed feature. One billion dollars might actually be low for all the profit Apple potentially lost; but it would certainly have been less had only the infringed features been considered.

A substantial backlash in the US seems unlikely. This is not an issue that will resonate with the voting public in the same way as SOPA, PIPA or ACTA. But as IP owners look to register and enforce more design rights – and expansion of the Hague System makes international coverage easier – lawyers and their clients should keep in mind how the image of their 'black art' is changing.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Attorneys explain why there are early signs that the US Supreme Court could rule in favour of ISP Cox in a copyright dispute
A swathe of UPC-related hires suggests firms are taking the forum seriously, as questions over the transitional stage begin
A win for Nintendo in China and King & Spalding hiring a prominent patent litigator were also among the top talking points
Rebecca Newman at Addleshaw Goddard, who live-reported on the seminal dispute, unpicks the trials and tribulations of the case and considers its impact
Attorneys predict how Lululemon’s trade dress and design patent suit against Costco could play out
Lawyers at Linklaters analyse some of the key UPC trends so far, and look ahead to life beyond the transition period
David Rodrigues, who previously worked at an IP boutique, said he may become more involved in transactional work at his new firm
Indian smartphone maker Lava must pay $2.3 million as a security deposit for past sales, as its dispute with Dolby over audio coding SEPs plays out
Powell Gilbert’s opening in Düsseldorf, complete with a new partner hire, continues this summer’s trend of UPC-related lateral movement
IP leaders at Brandsmiths and Bird & Bird, who were on opposing sides at the UK Supreme Court in Iconix v Dream Pairs, unpick the landmark case and its ramifications
Gift this article