The Belgian Court of Appeal has told Google that it infringes publishers' copyright by reproducing their headlines. The ruling confirms a 2007 first instance decision that supported the claims of Copiepresse, which represents French-language newspapers in Belgium. It claimed the way Google News reproduces headlines and article extracts in order to create a search engine for news infringed its copyright. Google claimed the system produced large benefits for the publishers and could be opted out of. The decision underlines the uncertainty around the interpretation of copyright around Europe. In January last year a Paris court ruled that Google did not break its copyright laws by reproducing thumbnail images of visual works. Other countries have followed similar interpretations of copyright. Google is likely to appeal to the Cour de Cassation in Belgium, the country's highest court and may then seek to refer the case to the Court of Justice of the EU.