In the case of Gemma Ong aka Maria Teresa Gemma Catacutan v People of the Philippines on November 23 2011, the Supreme Court held that "the defence of denial is unavailing when placed astride the undisputed fact that there was positive identification of the accused". This case began 13 years ago, upon a complaint of infringement of the Marlboro trade mark by the Economic Intelligence and Investigation Bureau (EIIB). Armed with a search warrant, on September 25 1998 the EIIB went to the premises of one Jackson Ong where the accused, supposedly the spouse or common law wife of Jackson Ong, was found. The accused initially refused the EIIB entry but they were eventually able to search the premises and found several boxes containing boxes of fake Marlboro cigarettes.