New UK judge: FRAND anti-anti-suits could create ‘total mess’

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

New UK judge: FRAND anti-anti-suits could create ‘total mess’

james-mellor-comp.jpg

In his first interview since joining the bench, Mr Justice Mellor talks exclusively to Managing IP about why some FRAND litigation tactics are not sustainable

The newly appointed judge at the England and Wales High Court says judicial authorities may need to show restraint to avoid running into a “total mess” in FRAND patent disputes.

Speaking exclusively to Managing IP, Mr Justice James Mellor says the rising trend of anti-anti-suit injunctions is not sustainable.

“It does create a potentially very difficult situation. It is going to require some forbearance amongst judicial authorities across the world, otherwise we are just going to get into a total mess,” says Mellor.

Anti-anti-suit injunctions aim to get a court to stop the infringement proceedings of a company in an anti-suit injunction in another country. In each instance, one jurisdiction is pitted against another as standard essential patent owners and implementers go to war over fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) licensing terms.

At the MIP International Patent Forum earlier this month, counsel said a major concern for industries involved in FRAND disputes is that if companies continue to escalate their litigation battles, there is no telling where the trend will end.

Defining things in simple terms, Mellor notes that each patent is a monopoly granted by a particular jurisdiction, and that each jurisdiction has to have the power to rule on that monopoly right. “I suppose that’s the route of the problem, with multiple territorial rights at play.”

He adds: “You have to look at your own jurisdiction and not overstep it. There are certain jurisdictions around the world where they will say ‘you have overstepped the mark’; often that is disputed because the precise basis is not understood.

“We have to wait and see what happens with the anti-anti-anti-suit injunction trend.”

The full interview, in which Mr Justice Mellor also discusses why he moved to the bench, why a fully equipped patents court is so vital, and why ‘soft IP’ disputes are just as important as complex patent cases, will be published in due course.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

News of Singapore planning to streamline the licensing framework for foreign law firms and a partnership between Avanci and Xprize were also among the top talking points
In major recent developments, the court also ruled on another request concerning access to documents and appointed a new panel to the Court of Appeal
A new foundation in Chile is giving women in the IP community the mentorship, and visibility they’ve long lacked
The EUIPO is keen to stress the benefits of mediation as a means of resolving IP disputes, but do roadblocks remain?
Åsa Gustafson, global patent paralegal manager at Zacco, provides insight into the world of a paralegal, explains how she keeps abreast of legal developments, and reveals a passion for weaving
Alif Gultom and Andrew Diamond of Januar Jahja & Partners explain why Indonesia must adopt reforms against bad-faith filings and safeguard its trademark system for the future
In the third episode of a podcast series celebrating the tenth anniversary of IP Inclusive, we discuss the ‘Women in IP’ network and the current state of diversity within the profession
Practitioners, including two ex USPTO directors, say the Patent Eligibility Restoration Act could restore clarity and predictability to US patent law, though concerns remain
News of an alliance between two Malaysian law firms and the launch of a self-help video aimed at supporting IP professionals through menopause were also among the top talking points
Speakers at the EUIPO’s IP Mediation Conference discussed how lawyers can act in tandem with clients during mediation, and the importance of showing a united front
Gift this article