US courts in “disarray” over irreparable harm
Managing IP is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

US courts in “disarray” over irreparable harm

Attendees were updated on the confusing approach to irreparable harm in U.S. courts at the INTA Annual Meeting in the session The Presumption of Irreparable Harm: Don’t Stop Believing

Two Supreme Court decisions in the past decade threw the viability of this presumption into question. The first was eBay v. MercExchange in 2006 in which the Supreme Court announced a test for injunctive relief that required the plaintiff prove “that it has suffered an irreparable injury”. This was followed by Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council in 2008, which held that a party seeking a preliminary injunction must show that irreparable harm is “likely”, and not just “possible” as had been ruled by the Ninth Circuit.

Kent Raygor of Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton, said there had been “so much disarray in Federal Circuit and district courts since eBay and Winter.” Although eBay was a patent case and Winter was an environmental injury case, Raygor noted the effect on trademark cases had been profound. “Injunctions had long been a favored remedy in trademark cases,” he said.

Susan Kayser of Jones Day said different policies were leading courts to different approaches. The Fourth, Sixth and Seventh Circuits are courts where presumption still likely applies. Courts where it is unclear are the First, Third, Fifth, Eight, Tenth, Eleventh and DC Circuits, and the Federal Circuit. “This is leading to some uncertainty and some forum shopping,” said Kayser. The Second and Ninth Circuits are courts where presumption definitely does not apply.

In the Q&A section of the session, audience member David Bernstein of Debevoise & Plimpton noted that Ferring Pharmaceuticals v. Watson Pharmaceuticals also addressed the issue of irreparable harm. Bernstein filed an amicus brief in the case, which is on appeal to the Third Circuit, on behalf of INTA last year. The brief said the court should hold that a showing of likelihood of success under the Lanham Act continues to give rise to a rebuttable presumption of irreparable harm and that such a presumption is not inconsistent with the Supreme Court’s decisions in eBay and Winter. This longstanding presumption remains appropriate in Lanham Act cases, said the brief, because the injury that results from false advertising and trademark violations is inherently unquantifiable and, as such, irreparable.

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

A 36-member team from Zhong Lun Law Firm, including six partners, will join the newly formed East IP Group
The Delhi High Court sided with Ericsson against Indian smartphone maker Lava, bringing the companies' nine-year dispute to a close
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
Tennessee has passed the ELVIS Act, a law that fights against AI models that mimic the voice and likeness of music artists
Rob Stien, chief communications and public policy officer at InterDigital, says the EU has forgotten innovators while trying to solve an issue that doesn’t exist
As Australia’s Qantm IP leans towards being acquired by a private equity company, sources discuss what it could mean for IP firms
Law firms that are conscious of their role in society are more likely to win work, according to a survey of over 23,000 in-house professionals
Nghiem Xuan Bac Pham, managing partner of Vision & Associates, discusses opportunities created by the US-China rift as well as profitability issues facing IP practices
Douglas Leite and two of his colleagues were intrigued by Bhering Advogados’s mission to grow its patent litigation practice
Each week Managing IP speaks to a different IP practitioner about their life and career
Gift this article