The state of the IP union

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

The state of the IP union

Alice was the dominant topic in the AIPLA session "Addressing the Hot Topics of Today for Tomorrow's Business"

The first question that moderator Timothy Meigs of Beckton Dickinson asked the State of the IP Union Panel yesterday was: what keeps them and their clients up at night? The panel's subtitle was "Addressing the Hot Topics of Today for Tomorrow's Business," but the answer to this question was hardly a hot and fresh one: it's still Alice.

Philip Petti of USG Corporation commented: "It's sort of like we're sitting in the middle of the bus, and there's a crazy person at the wheel." Petti says he and his company feel the "reverberations" of the uncertainty brought on by Alice. From the statistics he's examined, "if our patents are tested, about 70% of them are going to fail," he said. "How do I advise my business people when I tell them we're going to put so much money into patenting that you can't even count on?"

As Microsoft's Micky Minhas sees it, Alice may be dissuading IP owners from other countries from patenting their products here, placing the US at a disadvantage. As China considers accepting patents for business methods, the US is heading "in the opposite direction," he said.

Pfizer's Adrian Looney praised Hatch-Waxman and the BPCIA for clearing the way for generics. But he also questioned whether, if the Alice decision had been handed down before the boom of generics, those pharmaceuticals that have saved many lives would even exist today. It was suggested that it is not just innovation in the biopharma space that Alice stands to inhibit. Qualcomm's Laurie Self said that funding for startups "depends on the VC community believing that you have a predictable right, an enforceable right." She added: "I really do worry that, through this constant diminishment of patent rights, you're making long-term research too risky an investment for startups."

Looney also pointed to the specificity of Hatch-Waxman litigation to one industry as a potential model for reform to 101 issues, which have been treated very inconsistently by the courts. Frustrating though the denial of cert for a number of recent 101 cases is, the panel conceded the Supreme Court has heard a number of IP cases and may still want to see the lower courts shake it out.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Attorneys explain why there are early signs that the US Supreme Court could rule in favour of ISP Cox in a copyright dispute
A swathe of UPC-related hires suggests firms are taking the forum seriously, as questions over the transitional stage begin
A win for Nintendo in China and King & Spalding hiring a prominent patent litigator were also among the top talking points
Rebecca Newman at Addleshaw Goddard, who live-reported on the seminal dispute, unpicks the trials and tribulations of the case and considers its impact
Attorneys predict how Lululemon’s trade dress and design patent suit against Costco could play out
Lawyers at Linklaters analyse some of the key UPC trends so far, and look ahead to life beyond the transition period
David Rodrigues, who previously worked at an IP boutique, said he may become more involved in transactional work at his new firm
Indian smartphone maker Lava must pay $2.3 million as a security deposit for past sales, as its dispute with Dolby over audio coding SEPs plays out
Powell Gilbert’s opening in Düsseldorf, complete with a new partner hire, continues this summer’s trend of UPC-related lateral movement
IP leaders at Brandsmiths and Bird & Bird, who were on opposing sides at the UK Supreme Court in Iconix v Dream Pairs, unpick the landmark case and its ramifications
Gift this article