TurkAegean: Is it abusive to argue trademark invalidity on absolute grounds?

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

TurkAegean: Is it abusive to argue trademark invalidity on absolute grounds?

Sponsored by

patrinos-logo.png
Greek flag over the sea

Manolis Metaxakis of Patrinos & Kilimiris Law Offices considers the implications of the EUIPO ruling in favour of the Hellenic Republic concerning the validity of the ‘TurkAegean’ trademark

The Turkish Tourism Promotion and Development Agency has applied before the EUIPO for the trademark ‘TurkAegean’ to designate tourism-related services. This trademark was initially accepted for registration by the EUIPO. However, the registrability of the mark was the subject of intense debate due to various absolute grounds under the EU Trademark Regulation (EUTMR) regime.

This was confirmed by decision C 58 927 of the EUIPO’s Cancellation Division of January 10 2025; under which, the application for a declaration of invalidity filed by the Hellenic Republic was upheld. It was particularly held that the trademark ‘TurkAegean’ was non-distinctive and descriptive, and, thus, invalid.

The EUIPO’s Cancellation Division was also called upon to rule on a preliminary issue; namely, whether filing an application for a declaration of invalidity could be regarded as an abuse of right. In this respect, it was held that unlike relative grounds, which protect a third party’s interests, absolute grounds are aimed at protecting general interests. It follows that the potential or actual economic interest pursued by the applicant for a declaration of invalidity is not of relevance and, consequently, there can be no question of an ‘abuse of rights’ while filing a declaration of invalidity of that type.

One must take into account that this kind of objection should, as a matter of law, be examined first; that is to say, before the deciding body gets into the substance of the case. The risk is obvious: a trademark that is actually invalid on absolute grounds may nevertheless survive because its registrability is linked with a third party’s potential or actual economic interests.

The above-mentioned ruling is well established. In fact, any approach to the contrary is not favoured by established EU case law. The purpose of the administrative procedure laid down in the EUTMR is, inter alia, to enable the EUIPO to review the validity of the registration of a trademark and to adopt, where necessary, a position that it should have adopted of its own motion (C-622/13, Section 42; C-450/13, Section 40).

In essence, this is about the fundamental principle of legality. All decisions concerning the registration of a sign as an EU trademark, which the EUIPO is called on to take under the EUTMR, are adopted in the exercise of circumscribed power and are not a matter of discretion (C-37/03, Section 47).

In plain words, there can be no immunity for a trademark that is actually invalid on absolute grounds. Legal certainty prevails.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Managing IP’s parent company, LBG, will acquire The Lawyer, a leading news, intelligence, and data-driven insight provider for the legal industry, from Centaur Media
In major recent developments, a team of partners broke away from Taylor Wessing to form their own firm, while Kilburn & Strode made a strategic UPC hire
General Court backs Christian Archambeau in some of his challenges against his departure, but dismisses others
Morgan Lewis adds three partners with technical depth, reinforcing the firm’s strategy to bridge legal and tech expertise in patent litigation
The firm posted a 13% increase in profit as well as a rise in overall revenue
Catherine Lee, one of Managing IP’s Top 250 Women in IP 2025, discusses her ‘soft’ approach to leadership and why building a community at work is important
Transactions specialists at Paul Weiss are advising on the high-profile split of Kraft Heinz into two companies, while Skadden is also involved in the deal
Youngmin Park joins us for our ‘Five minutes with’ series to discuss learning languages, moonlighting as a drummer, and why late is better than never
The record-breaking $1.5 billion settlement between the AI company and book authors may not lead to rapid resolution of other cases, say copyright lawyers
Leaders at two Brazilian law firms outline strategies to adjust to trademark fee changes at Brazil's IP office while urging clients to apply before September 20
Gift this article