Lenovo to pay InterDigital $138.7m for FRAND royalty

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Lenovo to pay InterDigital $138.7m for FRAND royalty

Rolls 2k-comp.jpg

The England and Wales High Court handed down one of the most hotly anticipated FRAND rulings for some time

The England and Wales High Court ruled today, March 16, that Lenovo must pay InterDigital $138.7 million for a global licence to its 3G, 4G and 5G standard-essential patents.

The ruling, by Mr James Mellor, was the most hotly anticipated fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) judgment in the UK since the Supreme Court’s decision in Huawei v Unwired Planet in 2020.

Today’s ruling confirms the Supreme Court’s approach in that case, in which it said courts in England and Wales are able to set a global FRAND rate when the licensor and licensee cannot agree on terms.

In today’s judgment, Mellor found that neither InterDigital's 5G extended offer nor Lenovo's lump sum offer were FRAND or within the acceptable range.

The final amount of $138.7 million is around 40% lower than what InterDigital had originally sought. Lenovo made a pre-trial offer of around $80 million but InterDigital’s proposal amounted to more than $337 million.

Mark Marfé, partner at Pinsent Masons in London, said it was predictable that neither offer was FRAND as both were so far apart.

“These cases are very time-consuming and expensive, and it is likely the parties would have sought to agree a rate among themselves to avoid the need for litigation if their offers had not been so far apart,” he said.

Josh Schmidt, chief legal officer at InterDigital, said: “We welcome the court’s decision as the first major SEP FRAND judgment that recognises that a licensee should pay in full for the past infringement of SEPs, and we agree with the court that this could be a powerful way of guarding against patent holdout in the future.”

He added that InterDigital plans to appeal against the decision, as certain aspects of it did not accurately reflect the company's licensing programme.

John Mulgrew, Lenovo’s vice president, deputy general counsel and chief IP officer, said the company saw the ruling as a “major win for the technology industry and the customers we serve”.

“It underscores both the importance of FRAND terms for patent licensing and the requirement of transparency by patent holders engaged in licensing practices.

“The court has confirmed that Lenovo is, and always has been, a willing licensee – even in the face of InterDigital’s supra-FRAND offers and behaviour as an unwilling licensor,” he added.

InterDigital had previously secured a series of wins in technical trials, but the FRAND case was heard separately.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Exclusive data reveals law firms are failing to go above and beyond for their corporate clients, with in-house counsel saying advisers should consider more transparent billing processes
Arty Rajendra and Gary Moss discuss why ‘thorough and intense’ preparation, plus the odd glass of wine, led to a record FRAND victory for their client
Monday’s coverage includes news of a potentially 'game-changing' trademark development in China and how practitioners are using AI
Managing IP gives a taster of the numbers behind this year’s IP STARS trademark rankings, and looks back at our 2025 award winners
Updates from IP offices, the shifting requirements of in-house counsel, and news of London 2026 were among major talking points on Sunday
Etienne Sanz de Acedo discusses the association’s three-year plan, what he is looking forward to in San Diego, and why London came calling for 2026
Professionals from three organisations reveal what led them to sponsor Brand Action and why doing so can build camaraderie
The results of a UK government consultation on the exhaustion of IP rights and an annual review published by the EPO’s Boards of Appeal were also among the top talking points this week
The decision disregards Perlmutter’s work at the US Copyright Office and comes at a time when strong leadership and expertise are crucial
Sources say the decision to fire Shira Perlmutter raises constitutional concerns and speculate on what the decision could mean for the country’s approach to AI
Gift this article