All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 Managing IP is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.
Sponsored content

Rare trademark judgment in Zimbabwe

Sponsored by


IP judgments in Zimbabwe are unusual, says Chris Walters of Spoor & Fisher Jersey. So the recent Supreme Court decision in Cairns Foods v Netrade Marketing is welcome

Both companies in this case sell jam. Cairn Foods has a trademark registration in class 29 for a mark comprising the word Sun and a device of various fruits, whereas Netrade has a later registration in class 29 for the mark Royal Sun.

When Netrade used an unregistered logo featuring various fruits and the term Mixed Fruit Jam, Cairn Foods sued for trademark infringement and passing off. There was proof of actual confusion.

First instance decision

The first court held the marks were not confusingly similar. Inexplicably it said that Cairn Foods’ registration was simply a device (seemingly ignoring the word “Sun”). The plaintiff appealed.

Appeal court overrules

The appeal court looked to South African law for guidance and cited a number of cases that deal with issues such as the need to consider notional use, the notional consumer, and the general impression of marks.

Unsurprisingly the court overruled the earlier court’s decision that the plaintiff’s mark did not comprise the word “Sun”, describing it as “so grossly unreasonable in its defiance of logic as to attract interference on appeal”.

The approach should not be to conduct aforensic audit of the two marks... the law does not require the court to closely peer at the mark and the offending mark to find similarities and differences”.

The correct testis an assessment of the impact which the respondent’s mark would have on the average consumer … deception or confusion is a matter of first impression not an outcome of study”.

The result

There was both infringement and passing off. The court granted an injunction.

There is nothing ground-breaking here, but it is a welcome addition to African IP jurisprudence!

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Managing IP presents the second edition of its Ones to Watch list, profiling 22 in-house counsel on the rise
Maria Herlitz Sundelius is a legal counsel at H&M in Sweden
David Degen is an IP counsel at Novartis in Switzerland
Jake Holt is a trademarks corporate counsel at Amazon in the US
Morgan Seisson is an European patent attorney at Nestlé Institute of Material Sciences in Switzerland
Daniella Valera is a legal assistant at Backus (part of AB InBev) in Peru
Fredrika Hellberg is a trademark attorney at Essity in Sweden
Hyeran You is a senior legal counsel at Samsung Electronics in South Korea
Guillermo Mier Y Concha Martinez is a brand enforcement manager at Red Bull in Austria
Charles Roger is a senior contract and licensing manager at STMicroelectronics in France
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree