Worries over Supreme Court’s flirting with 101
Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX
Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Worries over Supreme Court’s flirting with 101

The impact of the Supreme Court on Section 101 was debated in a star-studded update on the US patent system session at the AIPLA Annual Meeting featuring David Kappos and Laurie Self

supreme20court300.jpg

In a session moderated by Teresa Stanek Rea of Crowell & Moring, panelists raised concerns about how 101 was being distorted by recent court decisions such as Alice and Myriad.

“For any institution, individual or university that is making very large high risk investments in emerging areas of technology, having an appropriately broad scope for section 101 is critically important and it has been historically,” said Qualcomm’s Laurie Self.

Self said the initial threshold test of whether an invention is eligible subject matter for patent protection should be a coarse filter. “Unfortunately the Supreme Court keeps moving 101 in a direction that increasingly seems to conflate 101 analysis with the statutory criteria of 102 or 103 or 112. That’s really problematic for R&D intensive industries and organizations in this country.

“The good news is that, at least in our sector, the Supreme Court did not create a categorical ban for subject matter eligibility for so-called software related patents. But it keeps flirting with this notion of a categorical ban and that is problematic.”

Self added that another challenge in the current dialog over 101 is the tendency to invoke 101 to address concerns about so-called trolls. She also has concerns about confusing software patents with business method patents. “That is dangerous for our system. Quality issues are best addressed through the statutory criteria, not through 101, but we do see the Supreme Court confusing these issues in a way that create ­uncertainty,” she said.

david20kappos.jpg

David Kappos of Cravath Swaine & Moore, and former director of the USPTO, agreed, noting that it relies on a statutory requirement that was never meant to do the heavy lifting.

“It encourages 101 to become the answer to every question about the patentability of inventions, and it takes what was always meant to be a very coarse filter – the filter that should apply at the very end as a backstop – and makes it into a much more granular filter that is trying to lift more than it ­possibly can.”

He continued: “If there was any mistake made in the AIA, it was to leave 101 as 101. We should have moved it to 999! Leaving it as 101 encourages courts and others to get confused and think it’s the first thing they need to look at.”

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

An intimate understanding of a client’s sector is essential to winning new business, a survey of over 28,000 corporate counsel reveals
Counsel say a Federal Circuit ruling on the obviousness test for design patents may increase the time IP owners spend defending their rights
While the INTA Annual Meeting is over for another year, here are a few things Managing IP learned after attending IP’s biggest party
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
Four sources reveal which tools they have been using – or building – to help them with a range of tasks from invention generation to claim sufficiency
Managing IP reveals Wednesday's highlights, including a discussion on how AI is helping lawyers improve their "gut instinct" trademark decisions
Managing IP reveals Tuesday’s highlights, including an illuminating discussion celebrating women in the workplace and the challenges that remain
Dana Northcott, INTA’s 2024 president and associate general counsel for Amazon's IP team, talks about her work for the association
Managing IP reveals highlights from the INTA Annual Meeting, including law firms’ diversity and ESG concerns and a new beginning for a Chinese firm
Firms with a broad geographic reach are more likely to win work, especially from global companies with high turnovers, according to survey data of nearly 29,000 corporate counsel
Gift this article