SCOTUS justices must step up on software patents

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

SCOTUS justices must step up on software patents

Few topics in IP have proved as divisive and difficult in the past 20 years as patent protection for software. A sensible decision from the US Supreme Court in the Alice v CLS Bank case could help to bring peace

Contributions to the debate on whether or not patents should be granted for software are strongly felt, well argued and can become emotional. When the EU was debating the CII Directive, one MEP told me she had received more hate mail regarding software patents than on any other topic during her term.

The outcome of that debate, as many readers will remember, was that the Parliament overwhelmingly rejected the Directive and it was dropped. As far as European patents are concerned, computer programs “as such” remain unpatentable.

By contrast, the US has laid out the red carpet for software and business method patents, at least since the Federal Circuit’s State St decision in 1998 which gave us the “useful, concrete and tangible result” test. The 15 years after that coincided with the explosion of the internet and e-commerce, and the liberal approach to software patentability contributed to the continual growth in filings at the USPTO.

Put crudely, it was US = good, Europe = bad for software patents (unless you were an unbeliever, in which case it was Europe = good, US = bad).

But that simple distinction no longer stands. In Europe, the law is predictable and patent attorneys will tell you that a good invention, with a cleverly worded set of claims, can still get protection at the EPO. The data support this: the EPO grants about 2500 software patents annually. Even courts, such as those in the UK, that were robust in rejecting software patents, have softened. In the US, though, following the Supreme Court’s curious decision in Bilski v Kappos and the Federal Circuit’s split over CLS Bank v Alice, there is considerable uncertainty. (This was clear in two webinars we held last year, both of which you can still listen to – Software Patenting in Europe and Software patents after CLS Bank.)

In our latest issue, we published a survey of approaches to software patents in five jurisdictions (Australia, China, India, the US and the EPO). Each contribution addressed five questions about the patentability of software and strategies for protection. Gareth Fennell and Rob Genders, writing on Europe, say that EPO practice is “relatively settled” and it is a myth that the Office does not grant software patents. But John Collins, of Schwegman Lundberg Woessner, notes that the US is “arrived at a point of confusion and uncertainty”.

The diversity of approaches increases the further afield you look. Last week, Marks & Clerk published a preview of their High-Tech Report 2014, which provides data and analysis on software patents in the EPO, the UK, Germany, France, the US, Canada, China, Asean, Singapore, Australia and New Zealand. Mark Kenrick, a partner of the firm and one of the report’s authors, told me: “The inconsistency in this area is a problem. It leads to misunderstandings about what can and cannot be patented.”

The almost-theological divide between software patent believers and atheists will probably never be bridged, and it would be naive to hope for an international agreement. But a clear and well-reasoned decision from the Supreme Court in the Alice case could go some way towards reconciling those of different views. I know some observers are not optimistic, but let’s hope that, after previously ducking the issue, the justices will this time be up to the task.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Belgian attorneys have revived fax systems to protect clients’ filing rights, while uncertainty over exposed patent data has left firms struggling to answer questions about the breach
In his first interview since leaving Weil Gotshal & Manges, Chris Henry explains why he returned to Latham and how he plans to bolster its tech disputes offering
As GTA VI underlines the extraordinary value of gaming franchises, lawyers at Clifford Chance say investors need to know the IP behind their next deal can deliver the growth they are paying for
As ‘big law’ invests in IP litigation, trial firms are emerging as a valuable source of seasoned courtroom talent
Six hires across the IP spectrum reflect Orrick’s efforts to better serve tech clients across the IP lifecycle
David Stone, partner at White & Case, argues that the government’s planned reforms will modernise and futureproof UK design law, but leave two of the thorniest problems unresolved
Max Scott will join the firm’s IP transactions group in California, becoming the latest Weil IP partner to secure their future
Yonatan Drori, attorney at Drori-Stav IP in Israel, explains why foreign counsel must treat Israel’s patent disclosure requirements as an ongoing obligation, rather than a one-off formality
From Japan to Southeast Asia, domestic and regional firms picked up some of the biggest prizes, while key foreign players maintained momentum
Earlier this month, Managing IP had exclusively reported that the French arm of Taylor Wessing was minded to pull out of the deal
Gift this article