Federal Circuit issues narrow en banc Aqua Products opinion

October 04 2017

The long-awaited Aqua Products ruling is narrow – a result of different views on the judgment and the rationale that should be employed. The matter is remanded for the PTAB to consider the patentability of the proposed substitute claims without placing the burden of persuasion on the patent owner

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Patents

‘Boutique with more fuel in the tank’: Obhan Mason head on merger

Essenese Obhan shares his expansion plans and vision of creating a ‘one-stop shop’ for clients after Indian firms Obhan & Associates and Mason & Associates joined forces

Sukanya Sarkar, January 07 2026

Global influence of China depicted by an earth globe with the Chinese flag amidst a powerful, transformative atmosphere with fog. Rotation of the planet.

The year ahead: China eyes ‘problematic’ TMs and Europe’s FRAND predicament

From AI and the UPC to troublesome trademarks in China, experts name the IP trends likely to dominate 2026

January 07 2026

Patents

Goodwin hires prosecution expert from Cooley

Colm Murphy says he is keen to help clients navigate cross-border IP challenges in Europe

January 06 2026

Patents

happy new year, new year's eve, silvester, new years eve, sparklers celebration greeting card, new year card - Year 2026 in sparkler font and firework fireworks pyrotechnic, blue night sky background

Pro-patent policies and AI replicas: 2026 predictions

With 2025 behind us, US practitioners sit down with Managing IP to discuss the major IP moments from the year and what to expect in 2026

Sanjana Mishra, January 05 2026

Patents

Europe at night with glowing city lights, seen from space

Weekly take: Will 2026 see the wind of change come to Europe?

Large-scale transatlantic mergers will give US entities a strong foothold at the UPC, and could spark further fragmentation of European patent practices

Max Walters, January 05 2026

Patents

2025 New Year road trip travel with nature landscape and highway road leading forward for happy new year celebration in the beginning of 2025 concept, Photo by AI generative

Scoops, rankings and political wrangling: top stories of 2025

This year’s most-read stories covered uncertainty at the USPTO, a potential boycott of a major international IP conference, rankings releases, and a contempt of court proceeding

Sukanya Sarkar, December 23 2025

Patents

Exclusive: Pantech and Google reach landmark SEP settlement in Japan

The parties have agreed on a court-guided settlement covering Pantech’s entire SEP portfolio, marking a global first

Sukanya Sarkar, December 22 2025

Patents

Much ado about nothing? why Canada’s PTA may fall flat

The introduction of Canada’s patent term adjustment has left practitioners sceptical about its value, with high fees and limited eligibility meaning SMEs could lose out

Sanjana Mishra, December 22 2025

Patents

Data Fortress: A conceptual rendering of digital security with a file folder under lock and chain, evoking the ideas of confidentiality and digital safety.

Top trends in US privacy litigation and enforcement in 2025

With the US privacy landscape more fragmented and active than ever and federal legislation stalled, lawyers at Sheppard Mullin explain how states are taking bold steps to define their own regimes

Wynter Deagle , December 19 2025

Trademarks

Conceptual 3D render of a lightbulb with a hybrid AI brain, half circuit and half organic, floating in a pastel sky. Creative intelligence metaphor.

Exclusive: optimism for ‘hybrid’ AI adoption prevails

Viji Krishnan of Corsearch unpicks the results of a survey that reveals almost 80% of trademark practitioners believe in a hybrid AI model for trademark clearance and searches

Viji Krishnan, December 19 2025