Federal Circuit issues narrow en banc Aqua Products opinion

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Federal Circuit issues narrow en banc Aqua Products opinion

October 04 2017
Federal Circuit 165

The long-awaited Aqua Products ruling is narrow – a result of different views on the judgment and the rationale that should be employed. The matter is remanded for the PTAB to consider the patentability of the proposed substitute claims without placing the burden of persuasion on the patent owner

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

United StatesNewsPatentsNorth AmericaJurisdictions
more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Patents
Cracked piggy bank on desk with blurred person and documents, symbolizing financial distress and need for bankruptcy lawyer assistance.
Identifying and monetising IP in US insolvency proceedings
Evan Lazerowitz, attorney in Robinson + Cole’s bankruptcy and reorganisation group, offers key takeaways for IP interested parties in bankruptcy and insolvency proceedings
Evan Lazerowitz, June 25 2026
Rankings Analysis
2026 UPC rankings (3).png
UPC drives Western Europe rankings shake-up
While the UK sees heavy IP rankings movement, Germany’s new tiered UPC table signals a shift from early adoption to market maturity
Max Walters, June 25 2026
Patents
Ledeboer, Bernard_banner_highres.jpg
CEO of new PE-backed IP group sets out European growth plan
In an exclusive interview, Bernard Ledeboer reveals how a Consolid-backed group of firms wants to expand across Europe, invest in AI and centralise operations to compete at the top tier
Sukanya Sarkar, June 25 2026
Patents
Finding investor.jpg
Red and green flags: how IP firms pick funding partners
Not all private equity firms are the same, so leaders at four externally backed IP firms came together to discuss the frameworks they followed and how they ensured a cultural fit
Sukanya Sarkar, June 24 2026
Copyright
Motion blur, Race driver and race car racing on speed track, Car race on asphalt race track crossing finish line.
European law firms on grid for F1 IP dispute
Top-tier German and Spanish firms are among the advisers on a Europe-wide copyright and licensing tussle concerning the design of the track circuit in Madrid
Max Walters, June 24 2026
Patents
mip photo merged PG.png
Why Powell Gilbert believes integration gives it UPC edge
Partners Alex Wilson and Andreas Kramer say bigger law firm rivals don’t necessarily gain by having a wider jurisdictional reach
Max Walters, June 22 2026
Patents
Invest.jpg
Exclusive: Dutch IP firm VO to be acquired by private equity funder
VO, which has offices in the Netherlands, Belgium and Germany, is the second European IP firm to secure external backing this week
Sukanya Sarkar, June 19 2026
Managing IP Awards
Bardehle article image.jpg
Managing IP Awards interview: Prof Dr Tilman Müller-Stoy and Dr Tilman Müller
The Bardehle Pagenberg attorneys-at-law discuss the firm’s Managing IP EMEA Awards 2026 success, Unified Patent Court litigation strategy, and evolving European patent trends
June 19 2026
Patents
Nokia new.jpg
This week on MIP: Nokia and Lenovo ink deal | SCOTUS turns down Judge Newman
A patent battle between two legal tech companies and a loss for Elon Musk’s xAI against OpenAI were also among the top talking points
Sukanya Sarkar, June 19 2026
Patents
PharmaDelawareCOVER.jpg
Weekly take: Why Hikma decision shows external factors could have increased influence
With drug prices a hot topic in the US, courts are seemingly more reluctant to prevent the entry of generics to the market
Sanjana Mishra, June 19 2026
Gift this article