Split en banc Federal Circuit rules disparagement provision is unconstitutional

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Split en banc Federal Circuit rules disparagement provision is unconstitutional

December 23 2015
slants

The Federal Circuit has ruled that the disparagement provision in section 2(a) of the Lanham Act is unconstitutional, and reversed and vacated the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board’s holding that “The Slants” is an unregistrable mark. The en banc court was split, however, with a total of five opinions submitted

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Request Access or Login

Topics

Trademarks News North America Jurisdictions United States (National)
more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Copyright
Dunning_Angela_HRC.png
‘Shaping the AI landscape’: Cleary litigator reflects on trailblazing work
Angela Dunning shares why it’s an exciting time to be practising at the intersection of AI and IP, where the law is actively being made
Sanjana Mishra, August 31 2026
Patents
The hague.jpg
Beyond the headlines: Why The Hague is winning UPC work
The Dutch division is cementing its position as the UPC's primary alternative to Germany, with a consistent share of filings and growing market influence
August 31 2026
Patents
shutterstock_2665613761.jpg
Weekly take: Paying your dues no longer pays off
Junior lawyers aren’t unwilling to work hard, as some seniors believe; rather, they are rejecting traditional career advancement models that have limited payoff
Sanjana Mishra, August 28 2026
Patents
Rebekah Gay.jpg
‘Quiet the internal critic’: HSF Kramer’s IP co-head on achieving success
Rebekah Gay discusses overcoming self-doubt, supporting the next generation of women lawyers, and how changing client demands are reshaping IP practice
Sukanya Sarkar, August 27 2026
Patents
Disney,Plus,Logo,On,Tv,With,Popcorn,Bowl,And,Reomote
UPC update: Market share and mandates | InterDigital expands Disney offensive
New filing data suggests Germany's grip on UPC litigation remains strong, while Bardehle Pagenberg, Arnold Ruess, Hogan Lovells and Carpmaels notch up notable cases
August 26 2026
3D illustration of leadership success business concept rocket pa
Everything, everywhere: lessons in leadership from KASS International
In 27 years, KASS has expanded to seven countries in southeast Asia and is now eyeing further growth opportunities. Its CEO shares her perspective
August 26 2026
Trademarks
Mine Guner (002).JPG
Never out of style: why IP is an exciting ‘deep well’
Mine Güner discusses bridging law and business, taking the initiative, and why Taylor Swift helped put copyright on the map
August 25 2026
Trademarks
Wooden planks overlook a turquoise sea, with mountains in background. Perfect for travel blogs, product placement, and summer holiday promotions.
Finding a blue ocean: building an IP practice in Malaysia
Cindy Goh discusses why she launched Cheang & Ariff's IP department, the improving litigation environment in Malaysia and what to consider when using AI
James Nurton, August 25 2026
Patents
Business,,People,And,Handshake,In,Blur,Meeting,For,Hiring,Offer,
Stris & Maher makes patent litigation play with four-partner hire
Increased focus on adding patent litigation depth to the firm’s Dallas office was behind the boutique’s most recent hires
Sanjana Mishra, August 24 2026
Patents
Canada 2.jpg
Beyond the headlines: Can IPH maintain its Canadian run?
IPH's Canadian acquisitions are paying off on paper, but a couple of strong years may not be enough to show that the group's strategy has truly won over the market
Sukanya Sarkar, August 24 2026
Gift this article