Bifurcation and the UPC – comments welcome!

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Bifurcation and the UPC – comments welcome!

The possibility for judges to separate infringement and validity is one of the most controversial aspects of the proposed Unified Patent Court. What are your views?

upc-blog-150.jpg

Last month we published an article by Gottfried Schüll and Arwed Burrichter of Cohausz & Florack in Düsseldorf, Germany in which they argued that bifurcation – the German-style practice of separating the infringement and validity hearings of a patent dispute – should be welcomed.

“The UPC will make use of the bifurcation system, which makes perfectly good sense and is something that should be embraced and not feared, as it will provide clearer and quicker results,” they write.

At my invitation, Adam Cooke of DLA Piper in the UK has written a response, which addresses why some people have concerns about bifurcation. UK practitioners are typically sceptical about bifurcation, but Cooke argues that the UPC Rules take a balanced approach.

However he adds that the Rules could be further refined “to ensure that the central division's decision on revocation is actually issued before the regional/local division's decision on infringement, and/or that an injunction should not be enforced until after the decision on validity or unless the patentee has provided suitable security”.

We’ve temporarily opened up both articles so that subscribers and non-subscribers can read them. We’d also welcome your comments, which you can post below.

The articles will be published in our March issue, along with a selection of any comments we receive on this blog, on LinkedIn or via Twitter by February 20.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Powell Gilbert’s opening in Düsseldorf, complete with a new partner hire, continues this summer’s trend of UPC-related lateral movement
IP leaders at Brandsmiths and Bird & Bird, who were on opposing sides at the UK Supreme Court in Iconix v Dream Pairs, unpick the landmark case and its ramifications
Magdalena Bonde discusses Abion’s AI experiments and reveals why an entrepreneurial mindset and a willingness to learn about a business are essential skills
Partner Ginevra Righini explains how she secured victory for the Comité Champagne in its fight against an EUTM application for ‘Nero Champagne’
Volkan Hamamcıoğlu joins us for our ‘Five minutes with’ series to discuss meditation, tackling deadlines, and taking inspiration from Hamlet
A $110 million US verdict against Apple and an appellate order staying a $39 million trademark infringement finding against Amazon were also among the top talking points
Attorneys are watching how AI affects trademark registrations and whether a SCOTUS ruling from last year will have broader free speech implications
Patent lawyers explain why they will be keeping an eye on the implications of a pharma case and on changes at the USPTO in the second half of 2025
The insensitive reaction to a UK politician crying on TV proves we have a long way to go before we can say we are tackling workplace wellbeing
Adrian Percer says he was impressed by the firm’s work on billion-dollar cases as well as its culture
Gift this article