US: When is attorney-client privilege waived?

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

US: When is attorney-client privilege waived?

Sponsored by

katten.png

In Universal Standard Inc. v Target Corp. (S.D.N.Y., No. 18 Civ. 6042), the US District Court for the Southern District of New York addressed the question of whether sharing attorney-client privileged communications with a public relations firm destroys that privilege. The court found that Universal Standard waived the privilege by including its public relations firm, BrandLink, in emails discussing strategy related to the lawsuit.

By way of background, Universal Standard is a "size-inclusive clothing brand," owning a federally-registered 'Universal Standard' trademark. Universal Standard sued Target for trademark infringement and unfair competition, alleging that Target wilfully infringed upon the Universal Standard mark by offering for sale its own line of women's clothing called 'Universal Thread,' and allegedly using Universal Standard's brand concept. Universal Standard claimed that individuals would mistake Target's line of clothing for the "genuine high-quality Universal Standard products," damaging its reputation.

Target had raised questions about the content of specific emails, and, in response, counsel for Universal Standard asserted that the emails were privileged. Target disagreed, arguing (i) that Universal Standard waived any privilege as to the emails by failing adequately to describe the communications on its initial privilege log; (ii) that any attorney-client privilege was waived when the documents were voluntarily "disclosed to third-party BrandLink"; and (iii) that the communications are not protected attorney work-product.

Rejecting various arguments made by Universal Standard where third-party disclosure did not waive privilege, the court concluded that that the communications at issue were not protected by the attorney-client privilege. The court explained that information shared with a third party with specialised knowledge required to facilitate understanding between attorney and client (e.g. an accountant or translator) can preserve the attorney-client privilege. However, in the matter at hand, the emails involved public relations strategy regarding the lawsuit, which Universal Standard could have relayed directly to attorneys without the need for BrandLink's assistance. The court also found that the emails were not protected by the work product doctrine, because according to the court, Universal Standard provided only a "conclusory" argument that the emails were documents prepared in anticipation of litigation.

This case serves as a reminder to be thoughtful about who is included in communications between client and counsel.

ash.jpg
jakubovic.jpg

Karen Artz Ash

Jerry Jakubovic


Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP 

575 Madison Avenue

New York, NY 10022-2585

United States

Tel: +1 212 940 8554

Fax: +1 212 940 8671

karen.ash@kattenlaw.com

www.kattenlaw.com



more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Stobbs stands accused of interfering with the administration of justice after Brandsmiths’ client was subjected to an interim injunction for unjustified threats
The firm, known for its prosecution expertise, discusses its plans following the appointment of a UK-based patent litigation head and two new partners
Ed White at Clarivate provides an exclusive insight into the innovation power clusters reshaping Europe and the Middle East’s IP landscape, and why quality is the new currency of invention
In the first in a new podcast series celebrating the tenth anniversary of IP Inclusive, we look back at the network’s origins and discuss its mission
Rebecca Schwarz at Haynes Boone shares how her team secured victory for biopharma client RedHill in a licensing dispute involving a developmental cancer drug
News of a breakaway firm launching in Germany and a spike in vaccine-related patent applications were also among the top talking points
A flurry of hiring activity among UK firms suggests they are confident of mounting a serious challenge at the UPC
With the submission deadline approaching, we sat down with our research team to provide top tips on how to make your firm stand out
EA, owner of video games including Madden and The Sims, will be sold to a consortium including Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund and a firm owned by Donald Trump’s son-in-law
New arrival marks Mewburn Ellis' second partner hire in ten days as firm looks to boost patent litigation and prosecution capabilities
Gift this article