Europe’s new sport: fighting to host UPC divisions

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Europe’s new sport: fighting to host UPC divisions

New figures relating to patent litigation in Europe could reopen the debate about the way the Unified Patent Court system works in practice

Although there’s still plenty of trepidation about the way that the UPC system will affect IP owners and users, critics of the system have largely shifted from bemoaning it to preparing for it.

Judging from Managing IP’s European Patent Reform Forum in Munich last month, IP professionals are still keen to shape the system’s rules (they sent more than 70 sets of comments in the most recent round of consultations on the draft rules of procedure), and to divide along old pro-/anti-bifurcation lines. But it seems as though the patent profession is readying itself for the reality of the Unitary Patent and the UPC.

There is one aspect of the system that has received little coverage so far, however: how the level of patent litigation in EU member states will affect the ability of governments to host local or regional divisions of the UPC, and the composition of the judges that sit there.

Now, though, lawyers from Powell Gilbert, working with counterparts elsewhere in the profession, have done some digging into the statistics. Although Germany is the biggest centre of patent litigation in Europe, Managing IP has often heard suggestions (from London-based lawyers, it has to be said), that the numbers are skewed. Now the data gathered by Tim Powell and Penny Gilbert suggests that might well be the case.

They argue in a guest blog post for Managing IP that if cases are counted in the same way as in Germany, the recorded claims in the UK would be far higher. That is because German courts have a practice of splitting patent cases by patent and sometimes by party, and of treating claims for revocation as separate to any infringement action. This ramps up the number of individual claims, they say.

Powell and Gilbert also argue that the headline figures obscure the importance of the UK courts in the patent litigation strategies pursued by plaintiffs and defendants. More than a quarter of claims litigated in the UK are also the subject of lawsuits overseas, for example (far higher than the 2% figure for Germany).

Many London-based patent lawyers are sceptical about the touted benefits of the UPC for their clients. Some of them became a little more enthusiastic after London was awarded one of the Paris-based central division’s two national offshoots. This latest attempt to secure a greater role for the UK could be regarded as a new round of patent lawsuit landgrabbing on behalf of local lawyers. But there are two reasons why it merits attention. If the figures add up, then it is only right that the UK warrants more UPC divisions. Second, the UK’s patent courts and its judges are widely respected. Ensuring that they play a full role in the UPC is surely good for the system as a whole.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

A settlement between Philips and Transsion and a loss for AstraZeneca in the UK were also among the top talking points
Working with Harvey and Microsoft, the firm has been at the forefront of developing AI tools for its lawyers, and is now exploring new projects and business models
The Emotional Perception AI case, which centres on the patentability of an artificial neural network, will be heard next week
Developments included a court order related to InterDigital’s anti-anti-suit injunction against Disney, and clarification on recoverable costs
Partners at Foley Hoag examine how recent CJEU jurisprudence may serve as a catalyst for recalibrating US judicial reluctance to entertain foreign patent claims
International law firms have high hopes for their IP practices in Saudi Arabia, with many opening offices, but recruiting and retaining talent in the Kingdom presents unique challenges
Patrick Ogola joins us for our ‘Five minutes with’ series to discuss helping African entrepreneurs on the global stage, and explains why young lawyers should speak up
Heli Pihlajamaa, the EPO’s principal director for patent law and procedures, joins us to take stock of the unitary patent following its second anniversary
Kelly Thompson, chair of South African firm Adams & Adams, discusses self-belief, self-doubt, and the importance of saying yes
The renowned food brands were represented by a host of lawyers, including members of the firms’ IP teams
Gift this article