Why attorney fees may not be the key to reducing patent trolling

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Why attorney fees may not be the key to reducing patent trolling

Last week, the US Supreme Court accepted two patent infringement cases challenging the standard used to assess when attorney fees can be claimed. But could the decisions have an unintended effect on the activities of patent trolls?

Unlike in the UK and the rest of Europe, in the US each party usually has to pay its own attorney fees. But under Section 285, a court may decide in “exceptional” cases that one party should pay “reasonable” attorneys fees to the winner. Under Section 285, a case qualifies as exceptional if it is objectively baseless and brought in bad faith.

The two cases the Supreme Court accepted, Highmark v Allcare Health Management and Octane Fitness v Icon Health and Fitness, concern the standard for what constitutes an “exceptional” case in this context.

In Highmark v Allcare, insurance company Highmark asks whether the Federal Circuit must give deference to a lower court’s opinion that a patent claim is objectively baseless. After being unsuccessfully sued for infringement by patent licensing business Allcare, Highmark was awarded $5 million in fees by a district court but this was reversed by the Federal Circuit. One of two dissents said the decision by the appellate court “deviates from precedent” and establishes a review standard that is “squarely at odds with the highly deferential review adopted by every regional circuit and the Supreme Court in other areas of law.”

“The issue presented also has tremendous practical importance,” said Highmark in its petition for certiorari. “Litigation by patent assertion entities sometimes called ‘patent trolls,’ now accounts for a majority of all patent cases. The threat of an exceptional-case finding is a crucial deterrent to meritless suits designed to extort licensing fees.”

It is true that the high cost of defending a lawsuit in the US is what allows the patent troll business model to thrive, since it usually makes more financial sense for defendants to settle. But one problem with trying to reduce trolling by making it easier to collect attorney fees is that some trolls are shell companies with few assets to collect when fees are awarded.

Making it easier to collect attorney fees in patent infringement cases may actually have the unintended effect of increasing privateering, as legitimate companies concerned about the prospect of being ordered to pay the other side’s fees have more incentive to sue through a shell company.

The SHIELD Act, which also proposed to disincentivise patent trolling by awarding fees, attempted to avoid this problem by requiring a plaintiff determined by a judge to be an NPE to post a bond at the start of the litigation. In doing so, however, it sailed into the treacherous waters of attempting to define what constitutes a patent troll. Adam Mossoff of the George Mason University School of Law recently pointed out that under the SHIELD Act criteria, Intellectual Ventures would in many instances not be regarded as a troll, because it is the original inventor of many of its patented products. Besides, it is probably safe to bet that trolls, given sufficient incentive, would simply morph into a different shape to avoid fitting whatever definition anyone ascribed to them.

The truth, as unappealing as it may be to some of those who make a living from patents, is that reducing the large number of low-quality patents granted each year would put a significant dent in the future arsenal of patent trolls (an arsenal that is strengthened by the presumption of validity awarded to granted patents, which makes invalidating them more challenging).

A suggestion by Brian Love, an assistant professor at Santa Clara University, on structuring patent maintenance fees to discourage trolls by making old patents more expensive to maintain also sounds like a potentially effective way to disincentivise trolling.

But while there may be ways to reduce patent trolling, it is doubtful that we will ever eliminate it. As long as there are patents, there will probably be patent

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

The IP services provider is targeting further expansion as cost and efficiency pressures push law firms and in-house teams to rethink how they manage global portfolios
Two experienced UPC practitioners join the UK IP boutique’s growing German operation, with further recruitment planned as the firm expands in Europe
The Australian IP firm is taking on bigger rivals in Southeast Asia, betting that agility and transparent pricing can help it stand out
The firm has brought in former Weil IP leaders Doug Lumish and Jeff Homrig as it looks to deepen its patent, trade secrets and ITC bench
Bird & Bird helps GSK score a major injunction as the battle to become the UPC’s busiest division tightens, and overall filings reach a new monthly high
CEO Annette Bach explains how the Danish IP consultancy plans to build on its 65% profit growth while keeping external investment off the table for now
Belgian attorneys have revived fax systems to protect clients’ filing rights, while uncertainty over exposed patent data has left firms struggling to answer questions about the breach
In his first interview since leaving Weil Gotshal & Manges, Chris Henry explains why he returned to Latham and how he plans to bolster its tech disputes offering
As GTA VI underlines the extraordinary value of gaming franchises, lawyers at Clifford Chance say investors need to know the IP behind their next deal can deliver the growth they are paying for
As ‘big law’ invests in IP litigation, trial firms are emerging as a valuable source of seasoned courtroom talent
Gift this article