Editorial: Drop the Tenenbaum case

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Editorial: Drop the Tenenbaum case

There is a strange transition occurring in the IP world right now. Lawyers can increasingly be heard at conferences and cocktail receptions talking about how important it is to pick one's battles, and warning peers not to use IP law too aggressively. Engage, explain, let it go if possible: it sounds more like the mantra of a yogi than an IP lawyer, and yet we hear it more and more each day in trade mark and copyright circles. In an age when consumers have just as much ability to generate negative press as industry critics and seasoned journalists, IP lawyers are becoming ever more aware of how closely their actions and policies are tied to PR and brand image. And so the recording industry's continued belligerence is becoming somewhat surprising, even to the IP community.

Joel Tenenbaum, for example, has been ordered to pay $675,000 for illegally downloading 30 songs when he was in college. The jury that delivered the verdict could have found him liable for up to $4.5 million in damages. The companies that brought the suit are not backing down, despite the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) having officially halted its campaign targeting individual file sharers four years ago. And now that the Supreme Court has rejected Tenenbaum's request to appeal against the industry group, the case is adding fuel to the anti-intellectual property fire.

The harsh reality about the Tenenbaum case is that thousands of 20 and 30-somethings across the US hold their breath when they hear about such suits, wondering how they managed to fly under the radar all those years. According to Tenenbaum's Supreme Court petition, in 2008 the average American teenager had 800 illegally downloaded songs on his or her iPod. When it could just as easily have been you, it is hard to be convinced this level of punishment is justified. After all, didn't the last generation copy vinyl records onto cassette tapes for friends and record songs off the radio to their hearts' content? If they'd had the technology to get Lennon and Dylan free at their fingertips, wouldn't they have done it too? And might Lennon and Dylan have wanted it that way?

Tenenbaum did download and share songs illegally, and piracy is a problem. But total North American music industry revenues were still $26.5 billion in 2011. The music industry became used to astronomical profits during the CD era, but the digital age has perhaps forced them to become a bit more realistic. And at a time when IP owners are already fighting an up-hill battle to explain the importance of IP enforcement, it is arguably in the best interests of both the music and other copyright-dependent industries to avoid reviving the debate over individual downloaders, and just let this one go.

Eileen McDermott

Americas editor

Managing IP

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

A flurry of hiring activity among UK firms suggests they are confident of mounting a serious challenge at the UPC
With the submission deadline approaching, we sat down with our research team to provide top tips on how to make your firm stand out
EA, owner of video games including Madden and The Sims, will be sold to a consortium including Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund and a firm owned by Donald Trump’s son-in-law
New arrival marks Mewburn Ellis' second partner hire in ten days as firm looks to boost patent litigation and prosecution capabilities
In-house counsel and teams are invited to submit information for the 21st annual Managing IP Awards
The 2025 list of Rising Stars and Corporate Stars, produced by Managing IP’s accreditation title IP STARS, is now available
Eszter Szakács, partner at Danubia in Hungary, discusses women’s progression, workplace flexibility, and how to deal with imposter syndrome
Rob Fewery is a solicitor at Allwyn Entertainment in the UK
Piotr Rafalski is a patent attorney at Qemetica in Poland
Roshni Suchak is a legal counsel at SSP Group in the UK
Gift this article