Battistelli defiant in interview about EPO reforms
Managing IP is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Battistelli defiant in interview about EPO reforms

battistelli.jpg

EPO President Benoît Battistelli told us he believes he has the support of the majority of staff for his reform programme, and denied he was cracking down on freedom of speech, in an interview with Managing IP this week

battiselli-circle
Benoît Battistelli

In the interview, conducted by telephone on Monday, we asked him to respond to criticisms and protests during the past year, in particular regarding changes to EPO working practices and plans to reform the Boards of Appeal, as well as concerns about staff being suspended. He also discussed briefly the Office’s preparations for the Unitary Patent, and responded to accusationsthat the EPO favours large applicants. Asked if he felt that, given the events of the past year, he still had the support of EPC member states, the president said: “I not only feel that, but the facts are there. Last week [at the Admin Council meeting] the budget was unanimously supported by the Council. There is no more important issue in any organisation than the budget. Any government would be pleased to have its budget unanimously supported by the legislative body.” 

The interview lasted about one hour and we have published the full unabridged transcript (Managing IP subscription or free trial required).

No U-turn

epo20headquarters20in20munich.jpg
EPO headquarters

Battistelli insisted that reforms such as performance-based pay are "necessary to build the future of the organisation" and criticised the examiners’ union, SUEPO, for opposing them: “The trade union does not try to make a better deal for the staff, but wants to oppose any reform because they want to maintain control of the organisation.” He said the recent demonstrations in Munich and elsewhere only reflected the views of a minority of staff: “I am convinced I have the support of the majority of staff, and the results we are obtaining would not be achieved by staff which are not fully behind this policy.”

But he also left open the door to future cooperation with SUEPO, saying he hoped to sign a MoU with the union in 2016 to recognise it as “a social partner”.

Disciplinary proceedings are now underway against some senior members of SUEPO, and Battistelli said he would follow the recommendations of the disciplinary committee. “There are some individual behaviours which are not acceptable and which need to be sanctioned, such as harassment cases. It is not legitimate to harass somebody because you are a staff representative,” he commented.

Despite his robust defence of his position, though, Battistelli acknowledged that the reputation of the EPO has been damaged by recent criticisms: “It is true that politically this campaign has had some impact, we have to be realistic about that, and because of our protective roles we couldn't indicate what was at stake. We will be able in the near future to inform the public on the kinds of attacks and behaviour we have been victims of.”

Boards of Appeal

epo20strike-300.jpg
A protest at the EPO

Battistelli confirmed that he would make new proposals to reform the Boards of Appeal, where there are questions about productivity and independence, early next year. He made it clear that he would like to delegate the authority to manage the Boards: “It is a system that should be changed and somebody has to be responsible for that, and I prefer that we give this task to a new position.” He also hinted that the costs of appeals might have to rise: at present, the cost of the Boards is about €70 million, but the appeal fees only cover about 4% of this amount. Battistelli said he would prefer this proportion to be about 20% or 25%.

Some user groups have recently noted that there are vacancies in the Boards that need to be filled. Battistelli said it was “short-sighted” to suggest the backlog at the Boards has been created in the past few months due to positions being vacant, but also hinted that he might give some ground here, saying: “I am ready to look at this issue early in 2016 and if there are some nominations to be made we will propose them.”

As to where the Boards should be based, the president emphasised that to preserve the appearance of independence, they should be moved outside of the EPO premises, whether in Munich or another city. He also said it was necessary to have rules on conflicts of interest, to prevent members of the Boards going directly into private practice firms.

Follow up

These are just a few highlights from what Battistelli said. Please read the full interview for the detail. It is long, but we felt that given the gravity of the topics being discussed, the seriousness of the criticisms and the interest among readers, it was worth publishing in full.

Before conducting the interview, we asked a number of practitioners what they would like to ask the EPO management and also invited questions on our Twitter feed. We put as many of these as we could to Battistelli, and there were no topics he declined to discuss. Indeed, the interview lasted twice as long as scheduled. Of course, there may be other questions that people want answered, and we may follow up on these. We welcome your views using the comment function on this website, or on social media.

We know that what’s happening at the EPO is important to many readers, and we will continue to monitor it in 2016, and do our best to reflect all sides of the debate as fairly and clearly as we can.

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Ireland joining the UPC would offer plenty of opportunities to local attorneys but there are fears that upcoming referendum could get ‘lost in the noise’
Attorneys at four firms reveal the business opportunities that stem from patent licensing agreements in the life sciences sector
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
Counsel at four firms explain their lateral hiring policies and how they retain existing lawyers
Lori Gordon, who has joined from Perkins Coie, says she hopes to turn Goodwin into a 'premier' destination for PTAB work
The LMG Life Sciences Awards is thrilled to present the shortlist for the 2024 EMEA Awards.
Partners at LeanWill Law Firm, a newly launched domestic firm in China, discuss IP opportunities and which clients they plan to target
Each week Managing IP speaks to a different IP lawyer about their life and career
A survey of more than 25,000 in-house lawyers reveals that embracing technology could help law firms win new business
John Mulgrew, vice president of IP at Lenovo, says the EU's proposed regulation will readdress imbalances in the bargaining power of SEP owners and implementers
Gift this article