Product imitation is normally lawful


A recent (February 12 2007) judgment of Commercial Court 4 in Barcelona makes an interesting contribution to two issues: imitation and the requirements for imitation to be unlawful.

The judgment resolves in the first instance a dispute between two important groups in the business of making and/or marketing cosmetic products: L'Oréal Group and Coty or Coty-Astor Group. L'Oréal sued Coty-Astor for copying seven products:

  1. a face cream;
  2. a make-up base;
  3. a lip gloss;
  4. an eyelash mascara;
  5. a make-up base;
  6. an undereye make-up concealer; and
  7. an eyelash mascara

In addition to specific relevant product references, these products were each identified by means of the well-known trade marks L'Oréal and Astor (previously Margaret Astor).

Product imitation Under paragraph 6 of the judgment, the judge resorts to the Spanish Royal Academy dictionary to provide that "imitating is doing or endeavouring to do the same as another...


Please log in to read the rest of this article.

New to Managing Intellectual Property? Take advantage of one week’s FREE access and become a Managing IP member today. It’s free to join and the benefits start straight away.

Already registered?

Please make sure you log in to read the rest of the article.

Log in

Join us now

Gain 7 days FREE access when you register now.

Join here

profile

Managing IP

ManagingIP

ManagingIP profile

RT @The_IPO: Opening of the #UKChina IP symposium which began today http://t.co/rXGlBMypCo http://t.co/dEEsplCcNJ

Sep 1 2014 09:21 ·  reply ·  retweet ·  favourite
ManagingIP profile

Berne Convention to be extended to Guernsey; enters into force on November 21 2014 http://t.co/laG7rIuaUh @WIPO

Sep 1 2014 09:04 ·  reply ·  retweet ·  favourite
ManagingIP profile

China's National People's Congress announces establishment of IP courts in Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou http://t.co/eXcF0ggvSe

Sep 1 2014 04:27 ·  reply ·  retweet ·  favourite
More from the Managing IP blog


September 2014

The surprising rise of the PTAB

Patent owners have been shocked at how popular IPR proceedings at the PTAB have proven. As the USPTO mulls over changes and the Federal Circuit braces itself for a deluge of appeals, Michael Loney reports on how the PTAB is likely to evolve



Most read articles

Supplements