All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2022 Managing IP is part of the Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group.

EPO: Enlarged Board to consider entitlement to priority

Sponsored by inspicos-400px.png
Patent, EPO

Jakob Pade Frederiksen of Inspicos P/S discusses a technical board of appeal referral that deals with the issue of entitlement to priority

In consolidated cases T 1513/17 and T 2719/19, a technical board of appeal has referred two questions to the Enlarged Board of Appeal (EBA) on the issue of entitlement to priority. 

More specifically, the EBA is to consider if the EPC confers jurisdiction on the EPO to determine whether a party validly claims to be a successor in title to a previously filed application, from which priority is claimed. Phrased differently, if party B claims priority from an application filed in the name of legal entity A, is the EPO competent to assess if party B has validly obtained the right to claim priority from party A?

The matter is pending before the EBA under as G1/22 and G2/22. If the EBA holds that the EPO indeed has the authority to determined whether the party claiming the priority is the successor in title to the previously filed application, the EBA is further asked if a party B can validly rely on the priority right claimed in a PCT application in the case where a PCT application designates party A as applicant for the US only and party B as applicant for other designated States and regions, including the EPO, and the PCT application claims priority from an earlier application filed in the name of party A.

Such issues relating to priority arise frequently, for example in respect of applications claiming US priorities, in respect of which the inventor is named as the applicant, whereas the subsequent application claiming the priority is filed in the name of a corporate entity. For PCT applications, oftentimes, the inventor is named as the applicant for the US only, and the corporate entity is named as applicant for all other jurisdictions.

One possible outcome of the new referral is that the EBA endorses the ‘joint applicants’ approach which suggests that the priority claim of a PCT application commonly filed by joint applicants is valid if any one of the applicants is properly entitled to the claim to priority. In any event, applicants and their representatives are well advised ensuring an unbroken chain of assignments between applicants in cases where the applicant named in the priority application is not identically named in the application claiming the priority. 

 

Jakob Pade Frederiksen

Partner, Inspicos P/S

E: jpf@inspicos.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

More from across our site

Brand owners bemoan counterfeiters’ latest wheeze and say enforcement authorities should get more involved
Counsel at Bayer, Novartis, a generics company and other firms debate what the WTO’s patent waiver will mean in the short and long term
The patent office report found that stakeholders were still divided over subject matter eligibility but broadly wanted clarity
The UKIPO published the results of its consultation on AI and IP today, June 28, and plans to shake up the rules on copyright and data
IP consultancy Brandit is the first European intellectual property firm to announce plans for an augmented-reality presence
Patent owners and implementers weigh in on the PTAB Reform Act – its provisions, what it missed and its likelihood of success
Counsel from Blackbird, Unified Patents, two other companies and a law firm debate what new ways to avoid Fintiv mean for petitioners and patent owners
Counsel at six companies say experience, technical expertise and persuasion are some of the most important skills at the board
Nokia beats Oppo in Germany; Australia and EPO to continue PPH; Ed Sheeran nets nearly £1m in legal fees; Google backs down in €500m French appeal
Brand owners say Amazon’s new anti-counterfeit team up is welcome but warn that such partnerships are often made on the e-commerce platform’s terms
We use cookies to provide a personalized site experience.
By continuing to use & browse the site you agree to our Privacy Policy.
I agree