The ruling in CLS Bank v Alice further interprets the US Supreme Court's reasoning on so-called abstract subject matter.
However, some say the Federal Circuit is likely to remand the case for reconsideration by the district court on other grounds, since the claims at issue are stronger than those relating to the Bilski invention and should have passed the Section 101 test.
"The financial-related claims in the Alice patents are not as egregious as the hedging claims in Bilski, and it is unlikely that the validly issued Alice claims will be invalidated under Section 101 by the Federal Circuit," said Raymond Van Dyke, a software patent attorney in Washington DC.
Van Dyke referred to the decision as "the latest barrage in a 30-plus year long war against patenting software-implemented inventions".
At a glance |
|
Patent numbers |
5,970,479; 6,912,510; 7,149,720; 7,725,375 |
Invention |
Method of lessening settlement risk using a computer system |
Technology |
Financial services |
Patent owner |
Alice Corporation |
Other party/ies involved |
CLS Bank |
Court/judge(s) |
Rosemary Collyer, US District Court for the District of Columbia |
Jurisdiction |
US |
Decision |
Alice's patent found to be patent ineligible subject matter |
Key terms |
Business method, Section 101, Bilski, patentability |
The case stems from CLS's suit seeking a declaration that Alice's patents were invalid in 2007. Alice subsequently counterclaimed, alleging that CLS was infringing claims 33 and 34 of its US patent number 5,970,479 and all claims of its US patents numbers 6,912,510; 7,149,720; and 7,725,375.
The patents are "generally directed to methods or systems that help lessen the settlement risk using a computer system", according to the testimony of Alice's expert witness. The invention has been likened to the one at issue in the Bilski case, and is considered a pure business method patent.
In her decision, Judge Rosemary Collyer of the DC District Court said that - although some of the claims were tied to a computer and included system and product claims, as well as methods - "the abstract idea claimed by Alice's methods in claims 33 and 34 of the '479 Patent and each claim of the '510 Patent effectively preempt the use of an electronic intermediary to guarantee exchanges across an incredible swath of the economic sector".
As to the system and product claims, she said: "Just as the claims in Bilski II were not saved from the abstract exception because they may have nominally claimed a 'process' under § 101, nor can Alice's system or product claims be saved only by the fact they may nominally recite a 'computer' or 'manufacture'".
"The court said clearly that a method of doing business employing an intermediary is a basic, fundamental concept that doesn't get rendered patentable just because it's implemented on a general purpose computer," said William Tanenbaum of Kaye Scholer, who represented CLS Bank in the case.
"The implication is that if you're faced with these types of patents, there is a strong potential that this case provides a defence," he continued.
One in-house counsel at a large financial services company agreed, but could only speak to Managing IP anonymously, since the company is the defendant in a similar case to CLS Bank.
"The CLS Bank case illustrates one court's attempt to answer a very difficult question that was specifically left open in Bilski," he told Managing IP. "The case may go a little farther toward tightening the standard for eligibility than the Federal Circuit has gone thus far."
Alice has already appealed the decision, but Van Dyke said that it is unlikely to play out beyond that. "With the Federal Circuit and the [Supreme] Court having already immersed themselves on the issue, it is unlikely that this case will become a cause célèbre," he said.
But he qualified that statement by admitting he "could be wrong": "There are powerful forces pro and con software patenting, and many variables," he said.
Tanenbaum said he is confident the Federal Circuit will uphold the decision under the machine-or-transformation test, which requires recitation of a "particular machine".
He added that the ruling also has implications for the pharmaceutical, IT and other industries where business methods are commonly asserted.
Asked whether the decision effectively bars patents on all business methods, Tanenbaum said: "The short answer is yes."
But he said that the financial services industry will ultimately benefit from the certainty provided by the decision. "[Financial services defendants] will look at this opinion, kill the case on summary judgment and avoid a trial," he said.
But as for companies holding these types of patents, Tanenbaum said "they can't have it both ways".
Paul Martin Wolff of Williams & Connolly, who is representing Alice Corporation, did not respond to Managing IP's request for comment.