Federal Circuit issues narrow en banc Aqua Products opinion

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Federal Circuit issues narrow en banc Aqua Products opinion

October 04 2017
Federal Circuit 165

The long-awaited Aqua Products ruling is narrow – a result of different views on the judgment and the rationale that should be employed. The matter is remanded for the PTAB to consider the patentability of the proposed substitute claims without placing the burden of persuasion on the patent owner

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

United StatesNewsPatentsNorth AmericaJurisdictions
more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Patents
James + Mathew.png
Excited to offer ‘flexibility’ to clients: patent veteran on Pearce IP move
Mathew Lucas has joined Pearce IP after spending more than 25 years at IPH-owned firm Davies Collison Cave
Sukanya Sarkar, February 18 2026
Patents
Wooden and colored figures representing diversity and inclusion
DEI can make or break law firm pitches, despite survey findings
Exclusive survey data reveals a generally lax in-house attitude towards DEI, but pitches have been known to turn on a final diversity question
February 18 2026
Patents
Copy of MIP EMEA Awards 2026.png
Managing IP EMEA Awards 2026: shortlists revealed
Managing IP will host a ceremony in London on May 1 to reveal the winners
February 17 2026
Trademarks
Abigail_Wise_1-DIGITAL.jpg
Wise words: Lewis Silkin partner on rewriting the old boys’ network
Abigail Wise shares her unusual pathway into the profession, from failing A-levels to becoming Lewis Silkin’s first female IP partner
Max Walters, February 17 2026
Trademarks
Brass scales of justice balancing digital technology and human brain on wooden desk in law office representing AI ethics and legal decision making.
How to survive the AI revolution
There are some impressive AI tools available for trademark lawyers, but law firm leaders say humans can still outthink the bots
February 16 2026
Patents
Tesla Model X P100D interior logo at the rear trunk. Elon Musk Tesla motor company bage and logo at the rear part of a car
Tesla v Avanci: UK Supreme Court to face untested FRAND question
Lawyers at Simmons & Simmons look ahead to a UK Supreme Court hearing in which the court will consider whether English courts can determine FRAND terms when the licence is offered by an intermediary rather than an SEP owner
Joel Smith, February 16 2026
Patents
Drew_Jeremy_Formal.jpg
Breaking: Taylor Wessing’s first hire post-merger vote is IP partner
Firm says appointment of Jeremy Drew from RPC will help create ‘unrivalled IP powerhouse’, as it looks to shore up IP offering ahead of merger
Max Walters, February 16 2026
Patents
Stuttgart, Germany - 07-24-2022: Mobile phone with webpage of US International Trade Commission (USITC) on screen in front of logo. Focus on top-left of phone display.
‘Renewed interest’: firms bulk up ITC expertise as work increases
Law firms are expanding their ITC practices to account for the venue’s growing popularity, and some are seeing an opportunity to collaborate with M&A teams
Sanjana Mishra, February 16 2026
Trademarks
Untitled design (8) (1).png
PTAB powerhouse eyes trademark expansion
Erise IP has added a seven-practitioner trademark team from Hovey Williams, signalling its intention to help clients at all stages of development
Sanjana Mishra, February 13 2026
Patents
Roosendaal, The Netherlands - August 05, 2025: A mobile phone displaying the logo of Anthropic, with the company website, displaying the new Claude Opus 4.1 model in the background.
This week on MIP: UK publishers go after Anthropic, Meta | WIPO chief nears re-election
News of prison sentences for ex-Samsung executives for trade secrets violation and an opposition filed by Taylor Swift were also among the top talking points
Sukanya Sarkar, February 13 2026
Gift this article