Federal Circuit invalidates Smartflash patents in Apple dispute

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Federal Circuit invalidates Smartflash patents in Apple dispute

March 01 2017
Federal Circuit 165

The Federal Circuit has found invalid three Smartflash patents that an Eastern District of Texas jury had awarded $530m in damages for Apple infringing in 2015. The appeals court said Smartflash’s asserted claims are analogous to Ultramercial and distinct from DDR Holdings.

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

United StatesNewsPatentsNorth AmericaJurisdictions
more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Trademarks
Museum in tribute to Cristiano Ronaldo in Madeira in the city of Funchal. portugal, cr7
Estée Lauder’s ‘Origins’ downs ‘Cristiano Ronaldo’ TM application
UKIPO rejects trademark application for 'Cristiano Ronaldo Origins' following opposition by Beck Greener client in a rare opposition that considered actual use
Max Walters, April 16 2026
Patents
merger and acquisition business concept, join puzzle 3d
Hogan Lovells Cadwalader merger approved, debut planned for July
Partners at both firms have voted in favour of the tie-up, which marks ‘the largest law firm merger in history’
Noemi Distefano, April 15 2026
Trademarks
Futuristic Digital Map of Europe Showing Glowing Network Data Connections
Shoosmiths targets tech to aid European expansion
Head of IP, Andrew Brennan, and new partner, France Delord, explain how tech provides an edge in the battle for global brand owners’ business
April 15 2026
Patents
Patented Patent Copyright Law Business technology concept.
PTAB Section 101 reversals rise: what the decisions signal and how to position your next appeal
Anton Hopen, shareholder at Trenam Law, shares how counsel should construct Section 101 claims as early 2026 PTAB data shows reversals rising in technical cases
Anton Hopen, April 15 2026
Trademarks
EUIPO_2k-comp.jpg
Weekly take: EUIPO’s IP-backed financing vision could spell opportunity
Law firms should consider how they can help clients, as report calls on EU to use IP-backed financing to increase bloc’s competitiveness and attractiveness for businesses
April 15 2026
Patents
China rapidly rises as a sovereign microprocessor manufacturer
Appeals against CNIPA invalidation decisions: representative cases
In the final part of a series on challenging patent invalidation decisions in China, lawyers at Spruson & Ferguson and Marshall Gerstein share how courts adjudicate appeals
Siqi Wang, April 14 2026
Trademarks
Cast_doorMonokrohm-1.jpg
Where everybody knows your name: new IP boutique sprouts in Belgium
Stijn Debaene and Carina Gommers want Brussels-based Cast Law to be the place 'everybody wants to work'
April 14 2026
Patents
green-light-comp.jpg
Ashurst Perkins Coie moves forward with partners’ vote
The combination between Ashurst and Perkins Coie, which will create a $2.8 billion law firm, is expected to close in Q3
Noemi Distefano, April 13 2026
Trademarks
London skyline-comp.jpg
Breaking: Brandsmiths acquires Sipara, moves into UK’s top 10 TM filing firms
While Sipara will continue operating under its existing name and leadership for now, both firms plan to present a united front at the INTA Annual Meeting in London
Sukanya Sarkar, April 13 2026
Patents
Untitled design (16).jpg
‘Ahead of the curve’: Sheppard expands AI industry team
Sheppard has added quantum and robotics expertise to its AI industry team to help clients navigate questions around inventorship and IP infringement
Sanjana Mishra, April 10 2026
Gift this article