As we described in our briefing of March 2013, the clarity of a European patent is not itself a ground for opposition before the EPO. However, a patent that is amended during opposition proceedings must meet the requirements of the European Patent Convention (including the requirements of clarity), according to Article 103(3) EPC.
Article 103(3) thus opens up the possibility of clarity objections during opposition proceedings. A recent decision from the Enlarged Board of Appeal (G3/14) has now established the boundaries of such objections.
Decision G3/14 considered a number of scenarios, including those in which claims were simply deleted, or in which dependent claims were incorporated into independent claims. In such scenarios, the Board found that clarity objections could not be made.
Decision G3/14 has essentially confirmed the majority of previous Board of Appeal decisions in this area. It concluded that a patent as amended during opposition proceedings may only be examined for clarity when, and only to the extent that, the amendment introduces a lack of clarity.
The Board in G3/14 was careful to point out that Article 101(3) does not allow parties to scrutinise a patent thoroughly for compliance with all the requirements of the EPC, and that the legislator purposefully omitted clarity from the list of grounds for opposition given in Article 100 EPC. In other words, no general clarity examination is to be carried out during the European opposition procedure.
|
Edward J Farrington |
Inspicos A/S
Kogle Allé 2
DK-2970 Hoersholm
Copenhagen, Denmark
Tel: +45 7070 2422
Fax: +45 7070 2423