The Delhi High Court doubled the royalty granted to Ericsson in a standard essential patent dispute with Indian electronics company Intex yesterday, March 29.
Justices Manmohan and Saurabh Banerjee held that Ericsson had established the standard essentiality of its 2G and 3G patents at the interim stage and that the licence terms it offered Intex were fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND).
The court held that Ericsson was entitled to the full royalty it asked for, and not just 50% of its claims as initially awarded by a single judge at the court in March 2015. The exact rate has not been disclosed.
The division bench, in which at least two judges hear a dispute, handed down the decision after considering two separate appeals filed by Ericsson and Intex against the 2015 order.
Ericsson claimed it was entitled to the full royalty it asked for and Intex challenged the single judge’s interim determination that Ericsson’s patents were valid and had been infringed.
Intex relied on the UK Supreme Court’s 2020 Unwired Planet v Huawei ruling to contend that interim relief couldn’t be awarded in SEP disputes.
However, the high court’s division bench held that courts could grant injunctions or direct SEP implementers to pay at the interim stage.
“Any argument that the UK Supreme Court in Unwired Planet v Huawei has given the mandate that SEP disputes should not see interim relief is incorrect,” the judges said.
Intex also relied on an order passed by Justice C Hari Shankar at the Delhi High Court in Nokia v Oppo last year to argue that no direction for royalty or deposit payment could be made unless the fourfold test laid down in Unwired Planet had been fulfilled.
According to the test, courts must determine that the asserted patents were standard essential, the implementer’s technology infringed those patents, the royalty proposed by the patentee was FRAND, and the implementer was unwilling to take a licence at the offered rate.
But the division bench relied on another observation in Unwired Planet which found that interim relief for SEP disputes should be granted based on the particular legal regimes of different jurisdictions. The Delhi court applied this finding to hold that the reasoning in Nokia v Oppo was untenable.
According to the judges, the fourfold test casts an onerous burden on the patentee at the interim stage.
The judges said the court only needed to initially assess whether the patents were infringed, whether the implementer was an unwilling licensee, and if the royalty sought by the plaintiff was FRAND.
The Nokia ruling, in which Shankar refused to direct Oppo to pay an interim security deposit to Nokia for violating its SEPs, is also being challenged before the division bench.