Netherlands: Every dog has its copyright?

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Netherlands: Every dog has its copyright?

The court of appeal of The Hague recently ruled that the lifelike stuffed animal reproduction of a dog is protected by copyright. This decision once again proves that the threshold for claimants to invoke copyright is quite low.

Enesco, a toy company, manufactures and distributes a stuffed dog called "Boo The World's Cutest Dog". The stuffed animal is based on the actual dog Boo, which is a specially groomed dog that is quite famous. It even has its own FaceBook page, which has 17 million "likes". Enesco, acting as licensee in respect of toys related to the dog Boo, objected to the sale of a more or less identical stuffed dog bearing the name Pom by Dino Trading, claiming that the Pom toy was infringing Enesco's (licensed) copyright in the stuffed Boo dog.

In the Netherlands, copyright is vested in a work that is based on the creative act of the author, and that reflects the author's signature. Banal or trite designs fall outside of the scope of what is protected by copyright. In first instance, the court ruled that the stuffed Boo is nothing more than a realistic reproduction of a real life dog, and therefore, no copyright can be claimed. The Court of Appeal however, is of the opinion that the stuffed Boo is in fact protected by copyright, and that the sale of the Pom dog constitutes an infringement. Given that the definition of what constitutes a work enjoying copyright is harmonised, the Court of Appeal granted the injunction in respect of the EU territory.

This goes to show that little creativity is required to invoke copyright as an author. In any case, manufacturers of lifelike reproduction toys (such as stuffed animals or toy cars) are thrown a bone by this ruling, as it will strengthen their position as copyright owners.

dogs

Cleuver_Juriaan

Jurriaan Cleuver


V.O.Johan de Wittlaan 72517 JR The HagueThe NetherlandsTel: +31 70 416 67 11Fax: +31 70 416 67 99info@vo.euwww.vo.eu

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

In-house counsel explain why firms should provide risk management advice that helps them achieve their goals
Attorneys at four firms explain the AI trends they expect in the future, including a potential shift in who plaintiffs sue for copyright infringement
The dispute at the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court pits Dryrobe against D-Robe and will include a ‘genericide’ element
Novo Nordisk losing patent rights covering Ozempic in Canada and a US Supreme Court decision favouring Ed Sheeran were also among the top talking points
The court will hand down its ruling in Iconix v Dream Pairs on Tuesday, June 24, in a case that concerns post-sale confusion
Developments included a stay in a row concerning the UPC’s jurisdiction and a timeline for the rollout of the long-awaited new CMS
Jorg Thomaier, who has been head of IP at the German pharma company since 2010, will leave later this year and hand the reins to the company’s head of patents
Companies must conduct thorough IP due diligence – even if it may not be mandatory
Celia Cheah at Wong & Partners in Malaysia says she is aiming to tap into the Baker McKenzie member firm’s international network and expand its IP portfolio
A team of partners that joined Boies Schiller Flexner say they would like to double the firm’s patent litigation capabilities
Gift this article