Some of the most controversial provisions of the America Invents Act become effective this Sunday. The rest will be implemented in March next year. Panellists at IPO's Annual Meeting in San Antonio, Texas, shared some of their short term strategies with attendees.
Budget
James Trussell of BP America said "at least a couple of hundred thousand [dollars] would be prudent" to budget for potential post-grant proceedings. This is based on data gathered by AIPLA listing average costs, including lawyers' fees, of existing procedures such as inter partes reexamination and interferences.
But Russ Slifer of Micron Technologies said he is not budgeting any money from a petitioner's standpoint. "That's going to be a wait and see," he said. If forced to respond to a petition, Slifer said he's planning to treat it "like unexpected litigation – but we're hoping we don't get hit much with this".
Negotiate with outside counsel
Slifer said he is considering implementing a "rewards and penalty system" mandating a 10% to 20% reduction in fees if filings don't make it to the Office by the desired date. Slifer also suggested that outside counsel might consider filing free provisional applications for clients "as a safety net" to avoid malpractice claims.
Sue the USPTO?
Meanwhile, many at the Meeting were voicing their concerns about the new law. Some wondered who would be the first to challenge either the AIA or the USPTO rules crafted in response to it. While one lawsuit has already been brought by a Florida inventor who says the AIA's first-inventor-to-file provision is unconstitutional, most lawyers think those arguments are flawed. Other potential grounds for challenging the law include: 1) that the post-grant opposition provisions may constitute a violation of due process rights; and 2) that the so-called broadest reasonable interpretation (BRI) standard for construing patent claims in USPTO post-grant proceedings is inappropriate and contradictory to practice in the courts.
The 21st Century Patent Coalition has published a paper on the latter point, saying that "the proposed use of BRI to interpret patent claims in IPR and PGR [inter partes and post-grant] would result in prejudice to petitioners, patent owners and the public at large".
There is a chance that if a company with enough resources brings a lawsuit on one of these or other grounds, the Office could find itself in a Tafas v Dudas situation. This would be ironic as Kappos's term comes to a potential end, since one of his first moves after taking over as director was to scrap the controversial final rules package proposed in that case.