Analysis: why the Supreme Court overturned two patent specialists

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Gardens, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

Analysis: why the Supreme Court overturned two patent specialists

November 02 2011
middcrownct01-0-69.jpg

Mr Justice Kitchin and Lord Justice Jacob were clear that HGS’s patent for the Neutrokine-a protein was invalid for lacking industrial application. But five Supreme Court judges today disagreed. Why?

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Request Access or Login

Topics

News Patents United Kingdom (Northern Ireland) Western Europe Central & Eastern Europe
more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

IP Ones to Watch
Bishop_Julia_985-_INTA2023_00820-FULL-Retouched (2).jpg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Julia Bishop at Twilio
Julia Bishop is director of IP at Twilio in the US
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
Essity pressbild
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Fredrika Hellberg at Essity
Hellberg is an IP director at Essity in Sweden
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
Teemu Itala Profile Pic.jpeg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Teemu Itälä at Nokia
Teemu Itälä is head of legal and compliance for technology standards at Nokia in Finland
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
OneDrive_1_9-30-2022/Kinga Palińska_0035.jpg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Kinga Palińska at CD Projekt Red
Palińska is the business & IP law lead at CD Projekt Red in Poland
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
Armin.jpeg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Armin Schwitulla at Nokia
Schwitulla is the head of litigation management at Nokia in Germany
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
David Degen.jpg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises David Degen at Novartis
David Degen is senior IP counsel at Novartis, Switzerland
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
Demetrio.jpeg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Demetrio Roberto Cavicchia at Angelini Pharma
Demetrio Roberto Cavicchia is an IP director at Angelini Pharma in Italy
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
Paloma Almeida Headshot.jfif
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Paloma Almeida at Bosch
Almeida is the IP group leader at Bosch in Brazil
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
Amanda Luz.jpg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Amanda Luz at Adidas
Amanda Luz is brand protection manager - global at Adidas in the US
October 07 2026
IP Ones to Watch
SGhosh-2.jpg
IP Ones to Watch 2026: MIP recognises Samantak Ghosh at Avere Therapeutics
Samantak Ghosh is vice president of IP at Avere Therapeutics in the US
October 07 2026
Gift this article