Expert witnesses in patent litigation around the world
Managing IP is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Expert witnesses in patent litigation around the world

geek.jpg

Expert witnesses can be decisive in the outcome of patent cases, but rules on their use vary widely. We invited correspondents in Germany, Japan, the UK and US to discuss procedures and practical tips

geek.jpg

With so much IP litigation today being international, and involving an element of forum-shopping, parties have to weigh up many considerations when deciding where and when to bring an action, or how to defend it.

Some of these questions are purely legal: What rights do we have? Do we have standing? What actions are permitted in a particular jurisdiction? But many questions are also strategic: How long will a case take? What will it cost? How will it be decided? What evidence can be brought? Often, these strategic questions are decisive for the outcome of the dispute.

In patent litigation in particular, the role played by expert witnesses can be vital, especially in cases where the technology is complex and judgements about validity and infringement can be finely balanced. And yet the rules on the use of experts vary greatly between different jurisdictions.

Germany, Japan, UK and US compared

In a special feature published this month, we invited correspondents in Germany, Japan, the UK and US to describe how expert witnesses are used in litigation in those four jurisdictions, and also how parties can make the most of expert witnesses.

In Germany, courts recognise both court-appointed experts and party experts – though in practice they are only used in a tiny number of cases. Courts place tight restrictions on the use of court-appointed experts, while party experts may be of limited value and may even do more harm than good.

Japan also has different types of experts, and the role of judicial research officials and technical advisers is especially important in patent cases. Technical advisers in particular are now an accepted and well understood part of litigation in the country.

In the UK courts, experts play a vital role and can even be instrumental in the outcome of a case. Selecting the right expert and carefully instructing them is therefore a crucial part of litigation strategy. What is required of experts has been elucidated in a number of cases over the years and it is also important to consider personality issues: how credible will your expert be before a judge, particularly in cross-examination?

Similarly, in US litigation both consulting and testifying experts provide the court with invaluable assistance that may be case determinative (and a strong expert report may lead to pre-trial settlement). The standards expected of experts have been clarified in federal rules and case law and, as in the UK, the ability to select and prepare your expert is a key skill for litigators.

Comments welcome

We selected these four countries as they are among the most important in patent litigation globally; we may cover other countries in future issues if readers are interested, so please do let us know via the comments.

more from across site and ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Ireland joining the UPC would offer plenty of opportunities to local attorneys but there are fears that upcoming referendum could get ‘lost in the noise’
Attorneys at four firms reveal the business opportunities that stem from patent licensing agreements in the life sciences sector
We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP
Counsel at four firms explain their lateral hiring policies and how they retain existing lawyers
Lori Gordon, who has joined from Perkins Coie, says she hopes to turn Goodwin into a 'premier' destination for PTAB work
The LMG Life Sciences Awards is thrilled to present the shortlist for the 2024 EMEA Awards.
Partners at LeanWill Law Firm, a newly launched domestic firm in China, discuss IP opportunities and which clients they plan to target
Each week Managing IP speaks to a different IP lawyer about their life and career
A survey of more than 25,000 in-house lawyers reveals that embracing technology could help law firms win new business
John Mulgrew, vice president of IP at Lenovo, says the EU's proposed regulation will readdress imbalances in the bargaining power of SEP owners and implementers
Gift this article